- Apr 24, 2018
- 3,185
- 2,500
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
He would want to be very cheapShiel to us? No, maybe St Kilda.
We don’t need another inside mid type like Shiel, we need wingmen.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He would want to be very cheapShiel to us? No, maybe St Kilda.
We don’t need another inside mid type like Shiel, we need wingmen.
Midfield is pretty set. His overinflated contract is almost a bigger turn-off than his ability. That's a no from me.I know its a running joke, but its not a bad destination.
Blues as well. Would have cripps, kennedy and hewett doing the tough inside work. Two decent key forward targets. He's bound to hit one of them
Must be trueIts funny how just about every credentialed expert says we have a pretty good list.
Its funny how just about every credentialed expert says we have a pretty good list.
Yeah what do they know. They all must be wrong.Must be true
Some supporters had Essendon finishing top 4 this year. Ridiculous
No one can con a supporter base like Dodoro.
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, get SOS in to sort the list out. Strip it back and have a proper go. They could do worse. They have done for 20 odd years.
So you rekn it's a great list? Sakc the coach!Yeah what do they know. They all must be wrong.
PerkinsWhat do you mean by good list?
I'll agree the media pile-on is way over the top at the moment, but your list certainly isn't good.
It's not a top 8 list based on talent.
Your youth isn't much to ride home about.
There's a dearth of leadership in the senior group, and doesn't seem to be much coming through.
Senior players are below average and some drastically overpaid (Shiel).
Your list is at the very start of it's rebuild, there are many years ahead before it'll be good.
You keep your filthy hands away from Kinnear Beatson (although I'm happy for him to offer you advice on 1st round picks)If we are going to replace Dodo it has to be one of Melbourne,Brisbane’s,Sydney’s draft guru
Perkins
Hobbs
Cox
Reid
Ridley
Martin
Jones
Bryan
Draper
But yeah we have no talent. It’s not a complete bust the list like majority claim we just need to add more
There have always been talented players. Just need a core group of players (spine + genuine mids) taken within 3 years of each other to form the basis to build around. I don't know whether that's been obtained yet.Perkins
Hobbs
Cox
Reid
Ridley
Martin
Jones
Bryan
Draper
But yeah we have no talent. It’s not a complete bust the list like majority claim we just need to add more
not an icebergs chance in hell the Tigers look at sheil after the public sook fest he and Mark williams ran against Richmond when he lied about Cotchin concussing him when it was actually AstburyDespite the running joke with their age targeting, I genuinely think Cats would genuinely look at him if he’s on the table. I can’t see him desiring a move to a rebuilding side. Maybe the Tigers look at him.
Blues desperately need key position players and rucks. So I can’t seem them targeting shiel types.
lol so irrelevantnot an icebergs chance in hell the Tigers look at sheil after the public sook fest he and Mark williams ran against Richmond when he lied about Cotchin concussing him when it was actually Astbury
I’ve been wanting him gone for years.Unbelievable this bloke is still in the job. Is his contract ending this year? If not, just pay him out because he’s done nothing despite winning grade week every year for the last decade
You keep your filthy hands away from Kinnear Beatson (although I'm happy for him to offer you advice on 1st round picks)
best list manager job in football. there is no chance he would want to go to Essendon and not have a free swing or two every draft.
Who on Essendons list has any trade currency?
Draper, maybe, but he's almost untouchable.
Wright will go nowhere.
Merrett, but not a lot.
Parrish, Stringer might be rated internally. Elsewhere?
Is Walla going to play again?
Any bids on who you'd like to see at your club?
match the bid on the gift?You keep your filthy hands away from Kinnear Beatson (although I'm happy for him to offer you advice on 1st round picks)
I’ve been wanting him gone for years.
If Shiel gets traded becuase it’s been a failure there is no way Dodoro survives
Who would pay anything for Shiel? He was a front runner at GWS and he is a front runner at Essendon.
at least he was an AA front runner at GWS. Parker was dropping truth bombs on Saturday night, unfortunately for usWho would pay anything for Shiel? He was a front runner at GWS and he is a front runner at Essendon.
at least he was an AA front runner at GWS. Parker was dropping truth bombs on Saturday night, unfortunately for us
So what has been the issue for the 18 years before that?I don't think this is all of Dodo's doing, Rutten just can't coach, that is the main issue here.