Carlton 2024 - Are they being overestimated?

[fnerd]

Still premiership favs for mine.

 

[Randomizor]

Start of the year thought we were in the 4th-6th bracket. Not much has happened to change that view. We could get better and rise to upper reaches or be worse and be borderline top 8.

Comp is super even as we all know:

You’ll be top 6 for sure

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Its not even that we don't have any small forwards who could be considered 'targets', we get nowhere near enough from any of them working off Curnow and McKay's contests at the drop of the ball.

Curnow is seemingly our best lead up player and best crumber. It's an indictment on any small fwd who's incapable of crumbing goals in what really should be the easiest job in footy. They are the best KPF pairing in the comp at not being out marked and bringing the ball to ground yet somehow we seem completely incapable of crumbing off of them

 

[My Tilly]

Still premiership favs for mine.

Not even close!
You guys should have beaten em and you wouldn't be classified a premiership contender. Certainly a finalist but Carlton lack in far too many areas to be a serious threat.

Given Taylor will miss for GWS, it'll be interesting to see how Carlton fair against a team that many feel is the premiership favorite.