"If I invited you to lunch I think you're a winner, if I didn't I don't, but I just met you all. Life is long, opinions change. Winners prove me right. Losers prove me wrong."It also only reinforces the coaches existing opinions about who is good based on training form, rather than challenging it
I know we've been scarred in the past with coaches favourites, but we literally have a whole new ensemble from those days. If we can't have some faith that the guys we draft have an ounce of resilience and drive, then we're in for a s**t time.
And like big dub said, the level of competition in practice is scaled up as you get to pre season games. I also think we can underestimate how complex the 'systems' and tactics are especially within certain lines. Back in the day I don't think cohesion between players would have been AS important
Both ways obviously have their drawbacks.