Disappointing quarter, not taking any of our chances, they’ve taken all of theirs.
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 13
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 12 Winner: believe_it
VFL 2024 - Reserves Game Day discussion Rnds 2 - 21 (Merged threads)
- Thread starter Jimmae
- Start date
- Tagged users None
This Poole fella looks good.
Weird game, feels like we should be comfortably up, but are somehow down by 1.
Mirkov and Akuei aren't AFL or VFL quality. They are borderline premier league seniors quality.
I think Lemmy will be very lucky to remain on the list next season, one of the traits of a quality tall is that they read it early in the air, he's often nowhere near it, reckon he goes at the end of the season.
Marchbank looks really unfit and very much out of form. Definitely right call not to bring him back into the AFL side. At least 2 weeks away if not more.
Binns, Fantasia, Carroll all look like competent AFL players playing VFL. Carroll and Binns will probably have big games, just fit and consistent.
Durdin looks like a good quality footballer with good skills and knows how to position. Would suite the AFL team. I like him.
Cuningham skill level is above the rest, need to see him a bit more. Hasn't inserted himself in the game as hoped, needs a much much better second half. At this stage he would not be considered for selection.
O'Keefe has done a couple of nice things but more opportunistic things. Looks miles off AFL level. Not seeing him mark in the hands and handle it cleanly which is not a good sign.
Young is good at this level.
Moir miles away.
Wilson not having a big game but showing a bit.
Most VFL listed players don't look great apart from maybe Cahill.
Opposition are poor. Pretty unimpressed with our lot apart from a handful.
I think Lemmy will be very lucky to remain on the list next season, one of the traits of a quality tall is that they read it early in the air, he's often nowhere near it, reckon he goes at the end of the season.
Marchbank looks really unfit and very much out of form. Definitely right call not to bring him back into the AFL side. At least 2 weeks away if not more.
Binns, Fantasia, Carroll all look like competent AFL players playing VFL. Carroll and Binns will probably have big games, just fit and consistent.
Durdin looks like a good quality footballer with good skills and knows how to position. Would suite the AFL team. I like him.
Cuningham skill level is above the rest, need to see him a bit more. Hasn't inserted himself in the game as hoped, needs a much much better second half. At this stage he would not be considered for selection.
O'Keefe has done a couple of nice things but more opportunistic things. Looks miles off AFL level. Not seeing him mark in the hands and handle it cleanly which is not a good sign.
Young is good at this level.
Moir miles away.
Wilson not having a big game but showing a bit.
Most VFL listed players don't look great apart from maybe Cahill.
Opposition are poor. Pretty unimpressed with our lot apart from a handful.
Yes he is - was in the 2023 draft but missed out on being selected. Thought he had some good moments in the U18 Championships last year, didn't realise we'd picked him up in our VFL side.
D.O.B: 18-03-2005
i love a 90 meter penalty for the other team
They’re really managing Moir’s time. Barely been on the ground.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Binns work rate is insane. Could he not be a threat to Ollies position?
Unlikely at this stage, IMHO
- Moderator
- #642
He was a free hit NGA,
Poole's left foot is sublime....
I do wonder if there’s a spot for McMahon on our list. Probably not… probably gets found out at AFL level… and he just missed a soda directly in front of goal… but there’s something about him.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Fair,
All things being equal, who do you think he could “potentially” replace if ever comes the time?
Poole’s another winger. He’s zippy. But do we need another winger?
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Probably not, but do we have a winger with a left peg like that? Has been impressive.
No. We don’t. I’ve liked his game. He’s certainly got skills.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Jun 9, 2008
- 11,318
- 9,589
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Thanks to those watching and sharing thoughts.
Marchbank needs a few games in the ressies.. has barely played any footy all year and had a badly interrupted pre season. I want him back in the seniors but with form, touch & confidence.
Looks like Binns Carroll & Fantasia are stuck in the awkward “too good for VFL, not quite at the level for AFL” position.
Expected Cunningham to rack it up in the ressies. Disappointed to hear he hasn’t. I’d keep him there until he does.
Marchbank needs a few games in the ressies.. has barely played any footy all year and had a badly interrupted pre season. I want him back in the seniors but with form, touch & confidence.
Looks like Binns Carroll & Fantasia are stuck in the awkward “too good for VFL, not quite at the level for AFL” position.
Expected Cunningham to rack it up in the ressies. Disappointed to hear he hasn’t. I’d keep him there until he does.
Similar threads
