"Reputations are made in September"

[Damp Squarie]

https://www.fiveaa.com.au/sport/Fox-Footy-Scored-Every-Adelaide-Crow-And-11-Got-An-F

Fox Footy has published an Adelaide Crows player scorecard following the club’s disappointing GF loss to Richmond -- and eleven of them got less than five.

Rory Laird — 7

Kyle Hartigan — 5

Jake Lever — 4

Paul Seedsman — 4

Daniel Talia — 3

Luke Brown — 5

David Mackay — 4

Rory Sloane — 7

Rory Atkins — 6

Charlie Cameron — 3

Josh Jenkins — 2

Eddie Betts — 5

Tom Lynch — 4

Taylor Walker — 4

Richard Douglas — 5

Sam Jacobs — 7

Brad Crouch — 7

Matt Crouch — 8

Riley Knight — 4

Jake Kelly — 6

Hugh Greenwood — 4

Andy Otten — 2

...............................................
Cant argue with that...or can you?

 

[TheLeftFist8]

Fair ratings though Jenkins and Otten should've only got 1, Walker 3, Knight 3, Betts 4, Cameron 5, Atkins 5, Hartigan 6.

Only subjective differences of +- 1

 

[Vhaluus]

https://www.fiveaa.com.au/sport/Fox-Footy-Scored-Every-Adelaide-Crow-And-11-Got-An-F

Fox Footy has published an Adelaide Crows player scorecard following the club’s disappointing GF loss to Richmond -- and eleven of them got less than five.

Rory Laird — 7

Kyle Hartigan — 5

Jake Lever — 4

Paul Seedsman — 4

Daniel Talia — 3

Luke Brown — 5

David Mackay — 4

Rory Sloane — 7

Rory Atkins — 6

Charlie Cameron — 3

Josh Jenkins — 2

Eddie Betts — 5

Tom Lynch — 4

Taylor Walker — 4

Richard Douglas — 5

Sam Jacobs — 7

Brad Crouch — 7

Matt Crouch — 8

Riley Knight — 4

Jake Kelly — 6

Hugh Greenwood — 4

Andy Otten — 2

...............................................
Cant argue with that...or can you?

They're being very, very generous in some of those ratings.

Atkins with a 6?

Walker with 4?

 

[Big Gazoongas]

https://www.fiveaa.com.au/sport/Fox-Footy-Scored-Every-Adelaide-Crow-And-11-Got-An-F

Fox Footy has published an Adelaide Crows player scorecard following the club’s disappointing GF loss to Richmond -- and eleven of them got less than five.

Rory Laird — 7

Kyle Hartigan — 5

Jake Lever — 4

Paul Seedsman — 4

Daniel Talia — 3

Luke Brown — 5

David Mackay — 4

Rory Sloane — 7

Rory Atkins — 6

Charlie Cameron — 3

Josh Jenkins — 2

Eddie Betts — 5

Tom Lynch — 4

Taylor Walker — 4

Richard Douglas — 5

Sam Jacobs — 7

Brad Crouch — 7

Matt Crouch — 8

Riley Knight — 4

Jake Kelly — 6

Hugh Greenwood — 4

Andy Otten — 2

...............................................
Cant argue with that...or can you?

Well there was a clear breakdown between Sauce and the mids, plenty of times his taps went to places other than where the mids were.
Set ups were garbage....again.

 

[Scorpus]

https://www.fiveaa.com.au/sport/Fox-Footy-Scored-Every-Adelaide-Crow-And-11-Got-An-F

Fox Footy has published an Adelaide Crows player scorecard following the club’s disappointing GF loss to Richmond -- and eleven of them got less than five.

Rory Laird — 7

Kyle Hartigan — 5

Jake Lever — 4

Paul Seedsman — 4

Daniel Talia — 3

Luke Brown — 5

David Mackay — 4

Rory Sloane — 7

Rory Atkins — 6

Charlie Cameron — 3

Josh Jenkins — 2

Eddie Betts — 5

Tom Lynch — 4

Taylor Walker — 4

Richard Douglas — 5

Sam Jacobs — 7

Brad Crouch — 7

Matt Crouch — 8

Riley Knight — 4

Jake Kelly — 6

Hugh Greenwood — 4

Andy Otten — 2

...............................................
Cant argue with that...or can you?

Jenkins and Otten 0, Walker 1, Betts and Mackay 2, Douglas 3, Atkins 4, Kelly 5, Sloane 6, Hartigan 7

Jenkins really deserves negative infinity though

 

[Rave Slave]

Jenkins deserved a 10 for Richmond

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Likely lost to swans in semi

You guys would have beat us in the semi. We barely scraped home against you in the h&a match. You had it over us but just kicked yourselves out.

 

[Murray2503]

Jenkins and Otten 0, Walker 1, Betts and Mackay 2, Douglas 3, Atkins 4, Kelly 5, Sloane 6, Hartigan 7

Jenkins really deserves negative infinity though

Jenkins, Otten and Walker may as well stayed home as they were embarrassing.

 

[OzSparrow]

https://www.fiveaa.com.au/sport/Fox-Footy-Scored-Every-Adelaide-Crow-And-11-Got-An-F

Fox Footy has published an Adelaide Crows player scorecard following the club’s disappointing GF loss to Richmond -- and eleven of them got less than five.

Rory Laird — 7

Kyle Hartigan — 5

Jake Lever — 4

Paul Seedsman — 4

Daniel Talia — 3

Luke Brown — 5

David Mackay — 4

Rory Sloane — 7

Rory Atkins — 6

Charlie Cameron — 3

Josh Jenkins — 2

Eddie Betts — 5

Tom Lynch — 4

Taylor Walker — 4

Richard Douglas — 5

Sam Jacobs — 7

Brad Crouch — 7

Matt Crouch — 8

Riley Knight — 4

Jake Kelly — 6

Hugh Greenwood — 4

Andy Otten — 2

...............................................
Cant argue with that...or can you?

Not sure of some of these generous ratings:

Atkins - 6 (should be 2) - like a deer in headlights all day (including, but not limited to, his brain fart with the play on decision)
Talia - harsh at 3 (given the leaking dam that was our backline he did his part - should be 5 if Brown and Kelly are 5 and 6 )
Eddie - 5 (should be 3 if Charlie is a 3 - he was no better)
Douglas - 5 (should be 3 - one of the mids who were non-existent)
Greenwood - should be 2 (hardly sighted in the 2nd half)

I also think most of the 4s are very generous as well (special mention to Mookay and Seeds and Lynch).

Agree with the rest.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Not sure of some of these generous ratings:

Atkins - 6 (should be 2) - like a deer in headlights all day (including, but not limited to, his brain fart with the play on decision)
Talia - harsh at 3 (given the leaking dam that was our backline he did his part - should be 5 if Brown and Kelly are 5 and 6 )
Eddie - 5 (should be 3 if Charlie is a 3 - he was no better)
Douglas - 5 (should be 3 - one of the mids who were non-existent)
Greenwood - should be 2 (hardly sighted in the 2nd half)

I also think most of the 4s are very generous as well (special mention to Mookay and Seeds and Lynch).

Agree with the rest.

I thought Brown was fumbling with a bra strap in the first quarter.

 

[OzSparrow]

I thought Brown was fumbling with a bra strap in the first quarter.

Yeah missed him. Overrated at a 5.

 

[1970crow]

Yet no one saw this as potentially happening today. Everyone was so confident

Not me.

 

[1970crow]

More so our lack thereof IMO.

If everyone wasn't fapping about Pyke's make believe plan B that turned the game against Richmond at AO, they'd have been as worried as I was. Richmond were beating us by working hard to and around the contest, it was as plain as day that they stopped doing this after quarter time.

 

[1970crow]

I think our coaches need to get added to the list that failed to stand up.

Our forward line looks brilliant when it's open space, but when it's clogged up we consistently fail. We played with the tallest forward line of any top 8 side in the grand final and could not take a contested mark to save ourselves.

Meanwhile Richmond had the smallest and took plenty of marks in their forward 50.

No point being tall if you don't use it to your advantage.

We simply don't have a plan B for when our free flowing game plan is stifled, we just hope the opposition can't keep it up and we can break out into open space as the game wears on.

All my doubts about our coaching staff, that I'd put aside, have now come flooding back. We knew that Richmond was going to try and bring the game down to their level and we let them.

If we rated our forward in the same manner as horse polo handicapping, I'd say our forward group are +10 if our midfield give us a 5 goal advantage. As soon as our midfield are breaking even or a bit behind, our forward group quickly become negative handicaps. Playing the super slow and cumbersome Otto then makes it even worse.

 

[rezagun]

https://www.fiveaa.com.au/sport/Fox-Footy-Scored-Every-Adelaide-Crow-And-11-Got-An-F

Fox Footy has published an Adelaide Crows player scorecard following the club’s disappointing GF loss to Richmond -- and eleven of them got less than five.

Rory Laird — 7

Kyle Hartigan — 5

Jake Lever — 4

Paul Seedsman — 4

Daniel Talia — 3

Luke Brown — 5

David Mackay — 4

Rory Sloane — 7

Rory Atkins — 6

Charlie Cameron — 3

Josh Jenkins — 2

Eddie Betts — 5

Tom Lynch — 4

Taylor Walker — 4

Richard Douglas — 5

Sam Jacobs — 7

Brad Crouch — 7

Matt Crouch — 8

Riley Knight — 4

Jake Kelly — 6

Hugh Greenwood — 4

Andy Otten — 2

...............................................
Cant argue with that...or can you?

I thought camerons game was better than rats.

 

[Damp Squarie]

I thought camerons game was better than rats.

Marginally but yeah.

 

[rezagun]

Marginally but yeah.

Atleast he tried. *in rat is a frontrunner. Trade the campaigner to carlton.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Atleast he tried. ****in rat is a frontrunner. Trade the campaigner to carlton.

Hhmmm...why not
He can take his blond hair with him.

 

[Vhaluus]

If we rated our forward in the same manner as horse polo handicapping, I'd say our forward group are +10 if our midfield give us a 5 goal advantage. As soon as our midfield are breaking even or a bit behind, our forward group quickly become negative handicaps. Playing the super slow and cumbersome Otto then makes it even worse.

I think this is a really interesting concept and something I've been kind of mulling in my head if there's a way to quantify statistically for a betting system. Perhaps I should look into polo to get a better idea of what you're talking about.