- Banned
- #151
Seeing as we haven't played finals yet (in fact we finished 3 1/2 games and % out of the 8) I'd say it's highly debatable that we have the list to play finals yet. As everyone says we've got some nice top end talent, but we've also still got a lot of developing kids who are starting 22 and still need to take the next step if we're going to get somewhere.
Following from this if we don't make the finals it's not necessarily due to Dimma's coaching, it may be simply that some players don't come on as expected. That's not to say he shouldn't be under the spotlight. He's made mistakes in the past and has had increased scrutiny on him this year, but it's not necessarily the be all and end all.
I took a keen interest in Richmond last year and when in full flight you were pretty decent ... injuries played their part last year and looking at your recruiting this year its obvious you are trying to add to your depth so the same thing does not happen next year.
I have said in a few posts that given a good run with injuries a top eight finish should be in the ballpark and that should be what Dimma is tested upon.
Some of your more rose coloured supporters think top 4 is a chance but I see more anywhere from 7th to 10th.
I think you are a very realistic supporter and that you clearly think Dimma is the man. I also think he has been great for the RFC but am not convinced he has that x factor ... but (as long as we keep beating you) I would be gladdened to see that he did.
I would be nice to see the RFC in finals footy again ... I for one have missed you .... and US for that matter!