-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 15
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 14 Winner: BOMBERBLITZ and others
-
Sweet F.A. State of Origin
Join the Sweet FA and sign up for State Of Origin! Rivalry, Banter and New Friends made along the way in Bigfooty’s own AFL-Style simulated game. Everyone Welcome! -- Sweet Football Association - Since 2001 AD
-
Premier League Pre-Season Friendlies 2024
EUFA EURO 2024 - Group Stage ⚽ EPL 24/25 starts Aug 17 ⚽ Champs League 24 - Quals
Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?
- Thread starter Wosh
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Mar 25, 2019
- 8,284
- 16,571
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Geelong, Brisbane, Richmond and Hawthorn... What do they all have in common in the 21st century that Collingwood don't?
JustaBattler
Everyone Looks Better In Blue
- May 31, 2012
- 27,596
- 64,801
- AFL Club
- Carlton
The guys who like fudgeys calulator commentary on here all sing the same tune - Carlton's total dominance over Collingwood in GF don't count because they are ancient history but they keep validating how poor Carlton is by referencing- ancient history..
very self serving to those who can't count and often judging by their posts - can't read very well either.
Consider yourselves lucky Collingwood you didn't have to paly against any of the other prelim teams and got top play against the easy beats...and even then, even then, needed the worst umpiring call of the year to fall over the line...along with gaming the umpires in center bounce - that was as nice Collingwood game the game trick as well...
fancy having the AFL have to change the rules of the game to counter blatant thuggery as well....
yeah Collingwood are real good...LOL - everyone should be totally scared of the poize...cos Fudgey logic says so...
thanks for larfs fellas - see you in the next 'dead rubber'...
very self serving to those who can't count and often judging by their posts - can't read very well either.
Consider yourselves lucky Collingwood you didn't have to paly against any of the other prelim teams and got top play against the easy beats...and even then, even then, needed the worst umpiring call of the year to fall over the line...along with gaming the umpires in center bounce - that was as nice Collingwood game the game trick as well...
fancy having the AFL have to change the rules of the game to counter blatant thuggery as well....
yeah Collingwood are real good...LOL - everyone should be totally scared of the poize...cos Fudgey logic says so...
thanks for larfs fellas - see you in the next 'dead rubber'...
I think it upsets them how far they have fallen.
Way back when they were good, they were feared, now we all just laugh at them, even St.Kilda supporters do.
But there is hope, they showed some promise last year, let's see if they can back it up.
6 Grand Final appearances?
Hang on, no that's only Geelong.
11 top 4 finishes?
Hang on, no that's just Geelong as well.
The biggest membership base?
Richmond accounted for us for a couple of years, but the Pies are back in their rightful position.
The biggest crowds coming through the gate to watch them?
No, noone stands with Collingwood.
Powerhouse.
Nice melt.
How on earth can Carlton supporters expect any recognition of 'Carlton's dominance over Collingwood in Grand Finals', when we've play in 6 (7 if you include the replay), since Carlton have played in one?
Leftyforlife
Draftee
- Mar 18, 2023
- 12
- 9
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I think he meant 3 or more premierships.
That being said Collingwood deserves to be up there after Premierships in 2010 and 2023, and runners up in 2002-03.
And runners up in 2011 and 2018.
The only teams that have given their supporters a better bang for their buck than Collingwood in the 21st century are Geelong and to a lesser degree Hawthorn.
Leftyforlife
Draftee
- Mar 18, 2023
- 12
- 9
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Sydney sneaky one though. Premiers (2005, 2012). Runners Up (2006, 2014, 2016, 2022). Been disappointing in Grannys though.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 8,284
- 16,571
- AFL Club
- Carlton
To a lesser degree Hawthorn...
You have got to be having a laugh right?Hawks had one of the greatest teams ever assembled during their threepeat and their coach is widely regarded as one of the greatest of all time
The Pies havent gotten close to that level of success.
- Aug 24, 2020
- 7,491
- 6,717
- AFL Club
- Carlton
To a lesser degree Hawthorn...
Hawks had one of the greatest teams ever assembled during their threepeat and their coach is widely regarded as one of the greatest of all time
The Pies havent gotten close to that level of success.
Collingwood fans live in an alternative reality. A delusional reality. This thread is proof of that.
Put Hawthorn above us then, geeze you seem to get upset over the smallest things.To a lesser degree Hawthorn...
Hawks had one of the greatest teams ever assembled during their threepeat and their coach is widely regarded as one of the greatest of all time
The Pies havent gotten close to that level of success.
The point was, Collingwood are still going at the same rate as way, way back, when Carlton were feared, it's just now we have won the odd GF.
Carlton on the other Hand have dropped off the face of the earth.
The term I used was 'bang for buck during the 21st century', which has been going for 23 years.To a lesser degree Hawthorn...
Hawks had one of the greatest teams ever assembled during their threepeat and their coach is widely regarded as one of the greatest of all time
The Pies havent gotten close to that level of success.
12 years of which Hawthorn have missed finals.
Flags - Hawthorn 4, Collingwood 2 (Geelong 4, Carlton 0)
Grand Finals - Hawthorn 5, Collingwood 6 (Geelong 6, Carlton 0)
Preliminary Finals - Hawthorn 7, Collingwood 11 (Geelong 13, Carlton 1)
Years in Finals - Hawthorn 11, Collingwood 15 (Geelong 17, Carlton 5)
BANG.FOR.BUCK
Last edited:
Tell me mate, are you happy with Carltons 21st century?
And if you were a WC supporter, Geeze the difference there is huge.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 8,284
- 16,571
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Yes I'm tremendously upset
- Mar 25, 2019
- 8,284
- 16,571
- AFL Club
- Carlton
So Pies have just had more finals chokejobs? Good to know
Give him so slack, he supports Carlton.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 8,284
- 16,571
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Can I just double check... 4>2 is still correct yes?
Fudgeys calculator seems to be coming up with different answers again
Fudgeys calculator seems to be coming up with different answers again
Try not to use choke, I got told it was a no-no.(Just thought I would warn you, it doesn't worry me?
Yes we did, been doing it since the beginning of time, but it's still fun.
Do you think having no hope is better than losing them?
With a lot of Carlton supporters, it even seems the highlights for you are us losing.
Like I said before, 2022 was more fun than last year.
- Mar 29, 2019
- 9,739
- 15,288
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
OK, lets look at the other end of the equation - going to be a long time before anyone comes near this auspicious 21st century record.
Carlton - 5 spoons
Gold Coast - 2 spoons
GWS - 2 spoons
Melbourne - 2 spoons
North - 2 spoons
Richmond - 2 spoons
St Kilda - 2 spoons
West Coast - 2 spoons
Adelaide - 1 spoon
Brisbane - 1 spoon
Essendon - 1 spoon
Freemantle - 1 spoon
Bulldogs - 1 spoon
Carlton - 5 spoons
Gold Coast - 2 spoons
GWS - 2 spoons
Melbourne - 2 spoons
North - 2 spoons
Richmond - 2 spoons
St Kilda - 2 spoons
West Coast - 2 spoons
Adelaide - 1 spoon
Brisbane - 1 spoon
Essendon - 1 spoon
Freemantle - 1 spoon
Bulldogs - 1 spoon
JustaBattler
Everyone Looks Better In Blue
- May 31, 2012
- 27,596
- 64,801
- AFL Club
- Carlton
LOL - apparently anyone who challenges the very logic and arguments put forward by the Fudgey Calculator Club, by just referencing their own 'arguments' - is 'melting'...
same kind of Fudgey Calculator Logioc ( FCL ) that describes Collingwood getting absolutely pantsed as "dead rubber games"
and participation awards for losing - as "Bang for BUCK" - whatever that is supposed to mean...
thanks for the laughs fellas.
same kind of Fudgey Calculator Logioc ( FCL ) that describes Collingwood getting absolutely pantsed as "dead rubber games"
and participation awards for losing - as "Bang for BUCK" - whatever that is supposed to mean...
thanks for the laughs fellas.
- Aug 24, 2020
- 7,491
- 6,717
- AFL Club
- Carlton
If we tested the IQ of Collingwood supporters and compared that to the IQ of Carlton supporters, I am pretty confident in saying that the Carlton supporter IQ is much higher.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
