Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2024?


  • Total voters
    512

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carlton supporters carrying on a bit.
They have beaten Brisbane who are turning out to be a pretty average team.
Richmond who will finish bottom six and North Melbourne who will finish bottom of the ladder.

Interesting game next week when they face Fremantle who have gun rucks, midfield and a pretty dynamic back-line who like to run and carry (as Carlton do).
 
Dunno what game you were watching, but you seriously reckon Carlton would have barely scraped across the line by a point if Keidean Coleman hadn’t gone down at half time with an ACL?

And yeah, Walsh was a significant out, but Ashcroft is no mug either.

and c’mon, the rest of your outs were B listers that Carlton fans themselves tear their hair out over when they’re amongst themselves.
You do realise that Weitering is our most important player and our reigning B & F. - B Lister. Come on man

So our best and fairest and last years and the best finals player for the league are out. Probably covers anything Brisbane had out easily. Just them two -Walsh & Weitering

Then at half time we lost Sam Docherty. You know previous captain ,previous best and fairest. Did his ACL in the first quarter but tried to keep playing.

Your argument is silly. And you are making yourself look sillier the more that you try and prosecute it.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Carlton supporters carrying on a bit.
They have beaten Brisbane who are turning out to be a pretty average team.
Richmond who will finish bottom six and North Melbourne who will finish bottom of the ladder.

Interesting game next week when they face Fremantle who have gun rucks, midfield and a pretty dynamic back-line who like to run and carry (as Carlton do).
Fremantle aren't really playing all that well at the moment. If you're going to comment about individual games, they let the Roos to a what, 4-5 goal lead? Our game was a lot more commanding in comparison.

And as long as the Eagles are around, I don't think North will finish bottom.
 
Dunno what game you were watching, but you seriously reckon Carlton would have barely scraped across the line by a point if Keidean Coleman hadn’t gone down at half time with an ACL?

And yeah, Walsh was a significant out, but Ashcroft is no mug either.

and c’mon, the rest of your outs were B listers that Carlton fans themselves tear their hair out over when they’re amongst themselves.
Lots of ifs, buts , and maybes, however the game has been decided and Carlton won , so why bother bringing possible scenarios?
You could argue that Coleman and ashcrofts absence was the difference on yesterday's result, yeah ?
 
Carlton will be 6th at the end of the round. Problem for Carlton is many sides are looking good so far. Have to wait to see how they go against them.
 
yes, thankyou for being putrid long enough for us to catch up.

it wasn't all bad for you though, you did win 5 spoons along the way - you're way ahead of us there.

Yeah, and they try hard to take the piss out of us, right?

Colliwobbles:
  • 32 years (completed)
  • 22 seasons played finals
  • 8 Grand finals
  • 1 wooden spoon

Blueshakes:
  • 28 years (and counting - only 4 to catch up)
  • 11 seasons played finals
  • 1 Grand Final
  • 5 wooden spoons
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Yeah, and they try hard to take the piss out of us, right?

Colliwobbles:
  • 32 years (completed)
  • 22 seasons played finals
  • 8 Grand finals
  • 1 wooden spoon

The Blues:
  • 28 years (and counting - only 4 to catch up)
  • 11 seasons played finals
  • 1 Grand Final
  • 5 wooden spoons
You might be looking for a club history thread or something similar. You are in the "Who will be better in 2024. Carlton or Collingwood" thread.
 
Lots of ifs, buts , and maybes, however the game has been decided and Carlton won , so why bother bringing possible scenarios?
You could argue that Coleman and ashcrofts absence was the difference on yesterday's result, yeah ?

Sure …

… But I’m not the one claiming my team is a shoe-in for the 2024 flag after demolishing the Lions by a point, smashing a Tiger’s team with 3 men down by 5 points, and crushing the mighty North Melbourne Football club by a kazillion points …

… and that the only reason Carlton haven’t won the flag, the Coleman and the Brownlow already is because of injuries to a couple of decent players (Walsh, Wietering) + a bunch of others who now that they’re out injured are being martyred as the finest players to ever play the game.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

You might be looking for a club history thread or something similar. You are in the "Who will be better in 2024. Carlton or Collingwood" thread.

My bad.

I could have sworn this was the “The definition of insanity is Carlton fans repeating again and again x 28 the mistake of going too early with expectations” thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top