Toast 11 Prelims in 22 Seasons

[legendstatus]

Except we haven't.

Geelong (6) and Sydney (7) trump our (5) since 2000

Count the draw ( yes that’s right) and if we get into it in 2023 it’ll be 7.

Sydney are 6 not 7

 

[adammania9]

Count the draw ( yes that’s right) and if we get into it in 2023 it’ll be 7.

Sydney are 6 not 7

The replay shouldn’t be counted. We qualified for one grand final that year.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Count the draw ( yes that’s right) and if we get into it in 2023 it’ll be 7.

Sydney are 6 not 7

By what judgement of merit do you claim the drawn grand final replay as an extra year in which we have made the grand final since 2000?
How does our 5 years in which we have made the grand final exceed Sydney and Geelong's 6 years in which they have made the grand final since 2000?? As you claim!

Do familiarise me with your magical counting methodologies.

 

[domus]

Yup. But I was also to young to celebrate 1990, so 2010 is all I’ve had

I've seen us lose 11 grand finals, draw two and win two.

 

[WakeUpPies]

Got to love and hate being a Collingwood supporter. Of course our only premiership in recent times came against a team with an even worse record of winning flags … and it came in October!

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

It's the good and the bad. Love that we can continually contend basically every two years, and give us a shot at premiership glory. That's a fantastic record of consistency from our club, but in saying that, would’ve loved to have seen another 2 or 3 premierships in that time. Hopefully this year, we go that extra step, please!!!!........

 

[MightyPies2010]

We are very lucky to follow the biggest club in the land and get great value for money. We experience more highs on the rollercoaster than most other teams! C'mon Pies, 2 more wins for 2023!

 

[Carringbush2010]

We were in 1970 and you know what happened then!

You can add 77 until Phk up Phil had a brain fart.

 

[Carringbush2010]

Yup. But I was also to young to celebrate 1990, so 2010 is all I’ve had

I can give you the heartbreaking details of 77,79,80,81 if you want.

But I'd rather not.

 

[Carringbush2010]

It's the good and the bad. Love that we can continually contend basically every two years, and give us a shot at premiership glory. That's a fantastic record of consistency from our club, but in saying that, would’ve loved to have seen another 2 or 3 premierships in that time. Hopefully this year, we go that extra step, please!!!!........

Unfortunately it's more bad than good, yeah we contend tease all the time but it rarely ends in euphoria, it's mainly heartbreak.

 

[Premier Pies]

Mate, I was thinking about this thread just the other day and pondered "I wonder when it will get bumped"

Here's hoping your "bump" brings us a bit of good fortune in 2023 and our boys bring home the big prize

It seems like your bump did bring us some good fortune PonsfordMagpie

Great that our conversion of Prelim appearances to Premierships percentage has increased too

 

[nahnah]

Geelong and now us have shown in the last two years, if you knock on the door enough times you finally get allowed in.

 

[legendstatus]

By what judgement of merit do you claim the drawn grand final replay as an extra year in which we have made the grand final since 2000?
How does our 5 years in which we have made the grand final exceed Sydney and Geelong's 6 years in which they have made the grand final since 2000?? As you claim!

Do familiarise me with your magical counting methodologies.

I win