Autopsy AFL 2023 First Qualifying Final - Pies v Demons Thurs Sept 7th 7:20pm EST (MCG)

[PieLebo87]

Only the he plays for Collingwood card will get him off.

What is an example of that having worked in the past? Come on… so share…

 

[00Stinger]

they were but only really through melbourne being so abysmal. how many times did oliver roost a ball high into the forward 50 right to where moore and murphy were able to easily float across and spoil any marking attempt? incredibly stupid football.

I think it is partially a flow on effect of Melbournes high pressing defense. It essentially makes them flood their own forward half of the ground and leaves no space for the forwards to move/lead. Great for a defensive structure but effectively strangles their own forwards.

 

[danster168]

You need to stop with this regular commentary about Petty like he’s some super forward.

He has played 1 good game in his career up forward.

He is never going to be the answer to your forward line woes.

In his career? he'd been a career backman...and gun one at that.

 

[Sub_Zero]

Only the he plays for Collingwood card will get him off.

just like in 2002 and 2003 hey?

 

[danster168]

Tell me the difference between Hill’s tackle on Lever in Q1 v ANB’s tackle on Daicos in Q3 that resulted in a goal.

not a great deal but Daicos had a fraction more time and took more steps.

 

[ChristianBoy]

I’m trying to understand the difference between the Hill tackle on Lever in Q1 v ANB’s tackle on Daicos in Q3 - one results in a goal, the other is a ball up. Strange.

just like in 2002 and 2003 hey?

Yes when Cloke punched Edwards head into the stands and Rocca nearly broke Lades jaw. Both helped you win finals and Eddie still lobbied the AFL like it was an injustice.

Who remembers Eddie getting David Cloke on the FOOTY SHOW crying and pleading to let Jason Cloke play.

 

[lilJeffyG]

I see that your fear of playing Coll with Maynard is the obvious underlying motivation for this post - because it’s certainly not logic based on the facts.

So you would be ok, if you or someone close to you was playing footy and got knocked into next week? There should be nothing wrong with that right?

 

[PieLebo87]

Yes when Cloke punched Edwards head into the stands and Rocca nearly broke Lades jaw. Both helped you win finals and Eddie still lobbied the AFL like it was an injustice.

Who remembers Eddie getting David Cloke on the FOOTY SHOW crying and pleading to let Jason Cloke play.

Still waiting for your example of how Collingwood gets players off suspensions…

 

[SA HAWK]

Dees forwards shat the bed big time last night.

Straight sets would not surprise.

 

[Captivating]

Only the he plays for Collingwood card will get him off.

Lol. Please tell me that last time playing for Collingwood got a player free to play finals.

 

[Stax on the mill]

Two if not dropped anyway not that we have options with OUR injuries.

Hey Adam, it must be nice being able to interchange between 2 teams, both of whom you claim as your own. You’re a Saints man. Silly to pretend otherwise. End of season coming for you tomorrow.

 

[Ulahoopski]

watch his games? he's played about half the games because he couldn't make the team and then half the time he does play he's the sub. Did you not even watch the game last night. Tried to draw high frees about 3 times despite only playing 10 minutes. embarassing stuff.

Your blinkered view and overactive imagination is the only embarrassing thing here. How many games he’s played and whether or not he was the starting sub has ZERO to do with how he’s developed this year so obviously the answer to “have you watched his games?” is …. No.
113 disposals this season and just the 5 free kicks and you say he “has no other way to win the footy”. THAT‘S embarrassing. Did you see Rivers get done for HTB from a perfect Ginnivan tackle? Feel free to supply the moments when he “tried to draw high frees”. I won’t hold my breath.

 

[ChristianBoy]

Hey Adam, it must be nice being able to interchange between 2 teams, both of whom you claim as your own. You’re a Saints man. Silly to pretend otherwise. End of season coming for you tomorrow.

Hey Squeezer still confused and dazed?

 

[Fadge]

Actually, one of my best mates plays for the pies vfl team. So def no hatred. But if he had tackled he wouldn't have hit him in the head, yes I agree with you he choose to smother, but in the end the smother turned into a hip to the head.

Why the * would Maynard tackle Brayshaw when the ball was leaving his boot as he was approaching from 5 metres away?

He jumped in and attempt to Smother the ball that was already in flight.

Did you even see the incident that you're drawing and quartering Maynard on?

 

[Fadge]

There's no option to tackle. how? Maynard has the right to go for a smother. Smothering was the right option. it was just unlucky. Look I think Maynard is a good player but whilst I think he gets credit for doing the smallest of things, he should have no case to answer for this incident.

The cheering of Ginnivan was total cringe though. I don't get it anyway? It seemed more like Bronx cheers roasting. Cheering him for being the supersub at the 20 minute mark of the last quarter?...

Agree with your first comment.

And why is it wrong for a supporter base to cheer a young player who has had a tough season, who could potentially still play a big role in our upcoming finals?

 

[Fadge]

I do agree. I think he'll get off. But there has to be a send off rule. If Brayshaw plays, we win pretty easily. We replaced him with Bailey Laurie, so essentially a player down the whole game. A send off rule in the future would be fair.

Sounds as though there is a problem at Melbourne with their depth...

 

[No SPIN]

So you would be ok, if you or someone close to you was playing footy and got knocked into next week? There should be nothing wrong with that right?

Only a fool would make that gross generalization as a hypothetical - not worth responding to.
Are you 12 yo?

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

One of the rare occasions that the crowd cheered over a player getting knocked out.
Sickening to be honest.

 

[ChristianBoy]

Sounds as though there is a problem at Melbourne with their depth...

Im sure Collingwood would have been rapt to lose Crisp 5 minutes in.

 

[Sub_Zero]

One of the rare occasions that the crowd cheered over a player getting knocked out.
Sickening to be honest.

 

[danster168]

Your blinkered view and overactive imagination is the only embarrassing thing here. How many games he’s played and whether or not he was the starting sub has ZERO to do with how he’s developed this year so obviously the answer to “have you watched his games?” is …. No.
113 disposals this season and just the 5 free kicks and you say he “has no other way to win the footy”. THAT‘S embarrassing. Did you see Rivers get done for HTB from a perfect Ginnivan tackle? Feel free to supply the moments when he “tried to draw high frees”. I won’t hold my breath.

wow a player laid a tackled. what a super sub. Ginnivan literally ducked his head trying to draw a free moments later and got caught holding the ball too.

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Yeah condone it. Wouldn’t expect anything less to be honest

 

[Sub_Zero]

Yeah condone it. Wouldn’t expect anything less to be honest

lol

 

[Corn Cobbers]

wow a player laid a tackled. what a super sub. Ginnivan literally ducked his head trying to draw a free moments later and got caught holding the ball too.

Electric cameo from Ginnivan!

Pies through to the next game, that's all that matters!!

FLOREAT PICA!!!

 

[No SPIN]

Im sure Collingwood would have been rapt to lose Crisp 5 minutes in.

More midfield/stoppage time for McReery, Elliot, JD, to name 3.