Traded Brad Hill [traded with future 3rd to St Kilda for Acres, #10, #58, future 2nd and 4th]

[Spider Eater]

Your club offered him 900k for 5yrs you muppet. Thankfully they are smart enough to look deeper than Brownlow votes. Though they did give Hannebery 800k for 5yrs.....oops.....maybe they aren't smart enough!!

You have no idea how much they offered... complete specualtion.

 

[Freoforever86]

Freo supporters just don't get it. He does NOT want to stay in W.A. He wants to be in VIC with his woman. I bet Hill loves Bell at this minute, not.

So narrow minded.
Could also be filthy at saints for pulling what they did too.

there’s no resolution yet, for all we know it’s part of the plan

 

[Hogwild]

The truth is starting to dawn for St Kilda supporters just how far Peter Bell is about to bend their club over - and all they can come up with is " no Fremantle supporters ever posted about 2 first rd picks before today". That's because we've been sitting back and laughing!

 

[#gosaintas]

nobody will pay better than 6 and a future 2nd for Hill. You're club just looks batshit crazy. He can go to Melb or wherever but that offer won't be beaten.

 

[Freoforever86]

You have no idea how much they offered... complete specualtion.

As is the speculation of what bell asked for

 

[Veer Right]

As for us, well we offered 6 and a future which is massive over for anyone to see in the AFL.

Won't have an affect on players nominating us, as its not like we short changed Freo by offering a nothing pick.

For a non AA and one time B&F outside player..

You are spot on as well.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Like those times you had Goddard and Cloke in the bag... and I guess you missed Kelly because you just weren't interested?
Lol McCarthy... what a joke.
St Kilda poached Justin Plapp from Richmond one year which is equal to your McCarthy signing.
You can keep Hill... he hasn't made Freo a better team since moving there and 4 Brownlow votes from a full season this year.... less then Mitch Robinson. lol Keep him... enjoy.

 

[Scotland]

Last year West Coast looked to upgrade picks to satisfy Geelong. This year we traded them multiple picks and left nothing valuable on the table.

St Kilda have so far downgraded pick 6 after Freo asked for it (+).

Not comparable scenarios at all.

 

[Spider Eater]

Goddard and Cloke never nominated Fremantle. We're allowed to target everyone. Kelly never nominated Fremantle.

That would be like me giving Saints crap for missing Gaff and a host of players who stayed with their club... but I didn't.

Really the joke is on Saints for offering $900k for this 4 Brownlow votes nobody.

You're right about St Kilda targeting an average player like Hill though... getting too desperate.
Hopefully you get keep him.

 

[Scotland]

I knew this thread would eventually turn salty. Inevitable.

 

[Dockers26]

so we offered up: Pick 6 + 2019 2nd rounder + Blake Acres

and they rejected it. fmd.

Has that been reported as what you offered? This is all heresay. What you offered and what Freo requested is all speculation, none of which has been confirmed. The meeting today between the Saints and Freo may well have been Lethlean informing Bell that we are speaking to GWS to split a pick with a view to getting all deals done. Speak to you later.

 

[Scotland]

You're right about St Kilda targeting an average player like Hill though... getting too desperate.
Hopefully you get keep him.

Freo are paying their average player an average salary. St Kilda want to pay him more than Kelly, Daniher, Shiel etc.

 

[Spider Eater]

As is the speculation of what bell asked for

Which has not been brought up in my argument?
So??

 

[Spider Eater]

Freo are paying their average player an average salary. St Kilda want to pay him more than Kelly, Daniher, Shiel etc.

Point?

I don't want us paying him anything.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Freo supporters just don't get it. He does NOT want to stay in W.A. He wants to be in VIC with his woman. I bet Hill loves Bell at this minute, not.

Well he shouldn't have signed a contract then. Who knows, the only reason he might want to go to Victoria is Becuase you've offered him 900k per season?

 

[Dockers26]

he expanded on it. Blake Acres was thrown in as well.

Must be right then. Maybe that's why we asked for more, to take Acres off your hands.

 

[projectv]

Well at least the next few days are going to be interesting.

 

[projectv]

Well he shouldn't have signed a contract then. Who knows, the only reason he might want to go to Victoria is Becuase you've offered him 900k per season?

Is that not a valid reason?

You've never moved cities to basically double your salary? Can't blame him for that surely.

 

[Fireballs]

try again next year aints

 

[MightySaint]

try again next year aints

I always liked the aints name. Got a good sound to it

 

[BRAB]

Fascinating stuff.

If Freo honestly want more than 6 and our future 2nd (which could easily be a pick in the 20's, for all we know) then they can keep him, as far as I'm concerned.

6 is about all I would have been comfortable paying for him. He's no game-changer.

It's just Peter bell flexing to keep the fans happy.

He did it last year as well. Don't stress too much, it'll get done. Freo seem to feel the need to make everything difficult.

 

[Fireballs]

I always liked the aints name. Got a good sound to it

Typo

 

[catman2006]

Freo are entitled to ask for what ever, Saints wont lose face if Hill stays at freo longmuir will have a job to convince Hill to stay, but Saints will lose face if Hill moves to another melb club

 

[Fireballs]

It's just Peter bell flexing to keep the fans happy.

He did it last year as well. Don't stress too much, it get done. Freo seem to feel the need to make everything difficult.

Yep we should just give away contracted guns for nothing

 

[StCicatriz]

Has that been reported as what you offered? This is all heresay. What you offered and what Freo requested is all speculation, none of which has been confirmed. The meeting today between the Saints and Freo may well have been Lethlean informing Bell that we are speaking to GWS to split a pick with a view to getting all deals done. Speak to you later.

yes. morris reported it. in his article today.