I'm hoping geelong push for draft picks rather than hill. We have Clark and Duncan already on the wing and don't have a real need for himKelly isn't an upgrade on Brad Hill in the position Brad Hill plays. Kelly upgrades someone else in the stoppages and we have to find a replacement elite winger.
It's arguing that Patrick Cripps is an upgrade on Alex Rance.
If Kelly is out of contract and agrees to terms with Fremantle then Geelong get to try and squeeze as much value as they want before eventually making the trade anyway. Brad Hill doesn't get to go to the draft next season.
And it goes without saying, but what a player did last season doesn't help us win games the following year.