Player Watch #11 It's just Tom Papley !

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Corpuscles

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 3, 2006
7,616
406
Lunatic Park
AFL Club
Sydney
When Horse says ‘jump’, Tom replies ‘how high?’.

Typical Full Forward picking on ‘the little fella’!
I think it (his) was a legitimate serious question!

But, even so it has worked he has jumped > higher and higher> that's what a quality coach does and gets paid to do!

Had you pegged as having a 'little fella' syndrome! thks;)
 

The Gong

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 24, 2012
5,426
10,249
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Northern Districts Tigers
I would imagine it could be pretty similar to everyone on this board's issue with him. The gameplan is dysfunctional and the ball rarely gets into the forward 50 with any sort of organisation.
Yet Papley played in a Grand Final in his first season.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The Gong

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 24, 2012
5,426
10,249
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Northern Districts Tigers
The one we wee robbed.
Jumping to Carlton would also be a weird choice if it's about a more attacking gameplan. What's Carlton's win/loss look like this decade?

Horse is finally applying a more attacking gameplan so you leave just when he does because you want a more attacking gameplan?
 

SwansProudly

Premium Platinum
Sep 5, 2016
3,028
6,374
AFL Club
Sydney
Papley is a fav of mine. Early, not just lately. Mainly because his heritage family history and I admire blokes who are rookied and fight there way into the top 22. (Kirk in the beginning 3 tries to get there was the same)

He had a sensational year but was forced toshine when Buddy was out to be a target, almost a go to KP forward at times.
Carlton obviously had the need (taking fill in Betts) so likely they made the advances (just another Guess)
Then Swans are surprised that Daniher wants out now (immediately) so AND AS STATED clearly the option of move/trade was specifically linked. No desperation it seems???

Unsupported rumours about the head space etc are just that (BS!). He was quoted on record as "I will be professional"
If truly must leave he MUST maintain his value. Reset for 2020 and all is back to normal.
Every man alive has women's problems at some time, sometimes an obsession.
Like Bedders, Bloodied52 and many others, I loved watching Max Papley play.
I was so excited to see Tom sign with the Bloods.
I love watching Tom play.
It is any contracted player's right to request a trade.
Tom requested a trade. He was not traded.
Does Tom's girlfriend have man problems?
It would be nice if discussion was not how Tom's girlfriend "must move to Sydney", or Tom "needs a Sydney girlfriend".
#Respect
#GoBloods #ProudlySydney
 

Tedeski

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 2, 2006
16,370
18,166
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Sunnybrook Farm
Horse probably always insists on being miss Scarlett so he can go first, papley is sick of it
Maybe or maybe not!
Every club has players that are rubbed up the wrong way by their coach for one reason or another.
The more Horse may have rubbed Paps up the wrong way, the better a season 2020 I expect Paps to have.
OR
He just sooks it up with a long face & under performs, in which case, The Carlton Football Club is the perfect home for him, in that they have recruited similar players for 20 years now which has helped create the culture they now enjoy. When you mix top young draft picks with older, long faced, want away 'warrior/recruits' from other clubs, they have an unhealthy influence on these kids.
As talented & free flowing as GWS are as a team, it was the hard in & under slog of a game style that got them the the GF.
Once there, it was the hard fought slog, pushing the ball forward at all costs that won the Tigers the flag.

If teams are using our hard nosed defensive game style as a reason to lure best 22 players away from us, then those particular players will more often than not, enjoy some fairly attacking & clean footy at their new club, take Nick Newman for example, but it's highly unlikely that that style will win a p'ship, let alone consecutive finals which is what they will be confronted with from their opponent that will be using that hard contested brand along with some good finishing to put the icing on the cake.

I trust that Paps will get over it if the really is any issue with Horse.

Well probably! ;)
 

The King!

Chosen One
Aug 3, 2004
103,398
84,849
Backwater
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Cavs, Redsox, Patriots
Maybe or maybe not!
Every club has players that are rubbed up the wrong way by their coach for one reason or another.
The more Horse may have rubbed Paps up the wrong way, the better a season 2020 I expect Paps to have.
OR
He just sooks it up with a long face & under performs, in which case, The Carlton Football Club is the perfect home for him, in that they have recruited similar players for 20 years now which has helped create the culture they now enjoy. When you mix top young draft picks with older, long faced, want away 'warrior/recruits' from other clubs, they have an unhealthy influence on these kids.
As talented & free flowing as GWS are as a team, it was the hard in & under slog of a game style that got them the the GF.
Once there, it was the hard fought slog, pushing the ball forward at all costs that won the Tigers the flag.

If teams are using our hard nosed defensive game style as a reason to lure best 22 players away from us, then those particular players will more often than not, enjoy some fairly attacking & clean footy at their new club, take Nick Newman for example, but it's highly unlikely that that style will win a p'ship, let alone consecutive finals which is what they will be confronted with from their opponent that will be using that hard contested brand along with some good finishing to put the icing on the cake.

I trust that Paps will get over it if the really is any issue with Horse.

Well probably! ;)

If there’s an afl coach who is currently loved 100 percent by his entire playing list it would be a miracle
 

Corpuscles

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 3, 2006
7,616
406
Lunatic Park
AFL Club
Sydney
Like Bedders, Bloodied52 and many others, I loved watching Max Papley play.
I was so excited to see Tom sign with the Bloods.
I love watching Tom play.
It is any contracted player's right to request a trade.
Tom requested a trade. He was not traded.
Does Tom's girlfriend have man problems?
It would be nice if discussion was not how Tom's girlfriend "must move to Sydney", or Tom "needs a Sydney girlfriend".
#Respect
#GoBloods #ProudlySydney
I didn't see Max but remember at time of team of the century that many thought he deserved to be in it.

I agree I think the issues have been likely exaggerated and also feel if there was VERY serious desire for move then Swans would have got it done.
Tom seems to have great rapport with Buddy and I think he will get on with it professionally and Harley hinted at post trade time, they will do what they can re player off field welfare, to accommodate his needs whatever they may be?
Which is none of our BF business. Glad he is still a Swan , rooting for him in 2020!!!
 

Top Bottom