Landgraft
Norm Smith Medallist
- Dec 18, 2016
- 5,555
- 10,051
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Ok, let's say they were eligible. They wouldn't be in the conversation.
Simpson is more suited to AFL than VFL so can't really dominate games. Sort of the same for Parsons. More of a role-playing AFL type.
Scooter is a very solid mid at VFL but below the very best mids at that level.
Agree on Menegola. He would dead set smash the VFL. Made for it.
He only played a few games this year. So can't really say Obree had him to work with.
Parsons, Simpsons and Scoot have all definitely dominated games of VFL this year. If you look at the numbers players in the VFL team of the year are getting I'm not even convinced they wouldn't be better placed than those guys on raw disposals etc.