List Mgmt. 2022 AFL Draft & Rookie Draft

[Aphrodite]

 

[macky99]

He had Phillipou at 11 in August, has moved Hollands ahead of Hewett and Busslinger this month.
Also, this is his rankings, not his phantom draft.

Okay fair enough, that is surprising, as thought he would be rated much higher than that, but people have said, until all trades are done, it will probably make more sense following this as each club probably has different player rankings.

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Hollands is a great player, but I hope we don’t take him. He’s adding to more of what we have, more inside than outside midfielder who does his best work around stoppages, he’s a very good runner, but serious question marks on his ball use.
High possession, slightly lower impact player. I think he could find himself stuck in our 2s for a couple of years as I don’t believe he would have the ability to play a hybrid role early on in his career and midfield spots are hard to come by at the moment.

I’d love us to try move up a little and get Mackenzie. Finds time and space a little like Pendles and his ball use is smart and damaging.

Otherwise Hewett would be my pick, whilst he’ll have a great career as a midfielder, he’s the type of player that could have an impact playing forward whilst developing and waiting for a spot to open up in our midfield.

I wouldn't be surprised at all if WCE selected Hewett with their first pick....local boy who trained with them last summer....and I'm not sure they'd want to let one go who is right under their nose for the taking.

 

[GT619]

Hollands is a great player, but I hope we don’t take him. He’s adding to more of what we have, more inside than outside midfielder who does his best work around stoppages, he’s a very good runner, but serious question marks on his ball use.
High possession, slightly lower impact player. I think he could find himself stuck in our 2s for a couple of years as I don’t believe he would have the ability to play a hybrid role early on in his career and midfield spots are hard to come by at the moment.

I’d love us to try move up a little and get Mackenzie. Finds time and space a little like Pendles and his ball use is smart and damaging.

Otherwise Hewett would be my pick, whilst he’ll have a great career as a midfielder, he’s the type of player that could have an impact playing forward whilst developing and waiting for a spot to open up in our midfield.

Hotton for me

 

[Blue train 28]

Matty Lloyd gave Ollie Hollands a massive wrap on Trade Radio. Around being able to tag at school level as opposed to it being prohibited in NAB league, and his tenacity and ability to work through. Quoting 13 tackles in a game levels and still getting 30 possies. Did suggest perhaps needing to tidy disposal, which personally I don’t see. Playing inside in the kids comp and under constant pressure. Early seasons at top level would be more outside. His technique and vision are excellent. I don’t see an issue, particularly when compared to his contemporaries.

I’ve been watching the championship games. Recruiters were mainly comparing him to Darcy parish/jack macrae high disposals getters but not huge impact on games, his going to be a bloody good player but only Makes a lot of sensible decisions with the football But the recent two champ games I’ve watched I have been more impressed. With his damage. And can see him in the navy blue

 

[Coona Blues]

Hollands is a great player, but I hope we don’t take him. He’s adding to more of what we have, more inside than outside midfielder who does his best work around stoppages, he’s a very good runner, but serious question marks on his ball use.
High possession, slightly lower impact player. I think he could find himself stuck in our 2s for a couple of years as I don’t believe he would have the ability to play a hybrid role early on in his career and midfield spots are hard to come by at the moment.

I’d love us to try move up a little and get Mackenzie. Finds time and space a little like Pendles and his ball use is smart and damaging.

Otherwise Hewett would be my pick, whilst he’ll have a great career as a midfielder, he’s the type of player that could have an impact playing forward whilst developing and waiting for a spot to open up in our midfield.

Interesting take 43, you get great intel, but have trouble with this opinion offering. Hollands was a more outside player, who also played half back. Certainly his carnival was as a high output inside role, but underage and even earlier in the season, played more outside and his disposal and two way run was lauded fairly universally.

Yes he has been playing inside, largely from necessity, with many highly rated inside types quite questionable this year. We have moved beyond “needing” immediate impact, so has time to inherit a role.

I find it strange that in rejecting him as being only inside, you then throw up two names that have, over their journeys been more inside oriented.

I do not rate the top end of the draft overly highly and am looking for players who offer something we are short of. To me Hollands is exactly that player. His workrate is second to none in the draft and his skill set could, if necessary, transmit to multiple roles. The beauty is that he is flexible, but as some of our inside types age and slow he will have the scope to go in to the engine room with maturity.

Really wanting Port to be “forced” to trade it’s first pick, which gives us a realistic chance of Phillipou sliding.

 

[Blue__Balls]

I wouldn't be surprised at all if WCE selected Hewett with their first pick....local boy who trained with them last summer....and I'm not sure they'd want to let one go who is right under their nose for the taking.

Alternatively, draft a better player, and quietly inform Hewett that if whichever state he ends up in isn't to his liking, he can always request a trade after two years.

The go-home factor works both ways, and WC/Freo should really use it more aggressively instead of whinging about VIC players they draft wanting to come home.

 

[ferrisb]

If he lasts to our pick, I will Phillipou my pants...

 

[Bletch]

Big list update...

 

[Arr0w]

Big list update...

View attachment 1522533

Nice list mate

Think Scaife, Foster and Edmends underrated

 

[Sheephead]

If he lasts to our pick, I will Phillipou my pants...

Oh Sheezel mate, Tsatas no good, best you do a Humphrey and Jefferson the pants by George.

 

[Blues_1864]

It'll be pick 11 after Ashcroft is matched. But, yes.

Mmmm... Carlton @ Pick 11!

2000 - Trent Sporn
2012 - Troy Menzel

soyouresayingtheresachance.gif

 

[Revenant1965]

Nice list mate

Think Scaife, Foster and Edmends underrated

Gotta take Scaife... Fremantle NGA..

 

[4flagsin5yrs]

Two I like:

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/draft/afl-draft-2022-bolters-and-smokies-among-prospects-flying-under-the-radar/news-story/671462da74594405b64deddd0ca8898e

 

[Juice030103]

Mmmm... Carlton @ Pick 11!

2000 - Trent Sporn
2012 - Troy Menzel

soyouresayingtheresachance.gif

Menzel was a good player in my view just had a lot of external issues. Maybe my young age blindsided me but he was good

 

[Blues_1864]

Menzel was a good player in my view just had a lot of external issues. Maybe my young age blindsided me but he was good

Yep. He could play, no worries. But he could take or leave AFL, his whole career, it wasn't just a Carlton thing. It's a shame we spent a first-rounder on him, in that respect.

 

[Jimmae]

This bloke just got an invite to the combine for testing, seems an interesting outside-leaning midfield prospect for later on:

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Arr0w lets just say hypothetically we've traded up to 6/8/9 with Gold Coast/Port/Bowes pick or we've even made it to pick 11 as we currently stand and Wardlaw's shockingly dropped out of the top 5 due to his bung hammies and is still on the board. Humphrey, Wardlaw, Hotton are all still available and our list is as is. Who you going with?

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Hollands is a great player, but I hope we don’t take him. He’s adding to more of what we have, more inside than outside midfielder who does his best work around stoppages, he’s a very good runner, but serious question marks on his ball use.
High possession, slightly lower impact player. I think he could find himself stuck in our 2s for a couple of years as I don’t believe he would have the ability to play a hybrid role early on in his career and midfield spots are hard to come by at the moment.

I’d love us to try move up a little and get Mackenzie. Finds time and space a little like Pendles and his ball use is smart and damaging.

Otherwise Hewett would be my pick, whilst he’ll have a great career as a midfielder, he’s the type of player that could have an impact playing forward whilst developing and waiting for a spot to open up in our midfield.

What about Bailey Humphrey?

 

[Blue_Fusion]

If he lasts to our pick, I will Phillipou my pants...

Then your pants will be Phillipou....

 

[Arr0w]

Arr0w lets just say hypothetically we've traded up to 6/8/9 with Gold Coast/Port/Bowes pick or we've even made it to pick 11 as we currently stand and Wardlaw's shockingly dropped out of the top 5 due to his bung hammies and is still on the board. Humphrey, Wardlaw, Hotton are all still available and our list is as is. Who you going with?

Going with a hammy specialist to check out Wardlaw

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

I wonder how high 10 + F1 gets us.

I would love a chance at Sheezel.

 

[Foucault1989]

Twomey has Phillipou at 11 - dare to dream...

Agreed. According to Calculating Cal we could have Busslinger, Phillipou and Hollands available for consideration.

 

[BlueJet]

As per every year

Nope.

 

[Foucault1989]

This bloke just got an invite to the combine for testing, seems an interesting outside-leaning midfield prospect for later on:

That is the best set of highlights I've seen this year. What's his story? It would make too much sense for us to draft him. We always miss out on the obvious choice.

 

[Sheephead]

Nice list mate

Think Scaife, Foster and Edmends underrated

Foster I like. Reckon he could be a real good project.

Lovelock I think is a late smokey.

I wonder how high 10 + F1 gets us.

I would love a chance at Sheezel.

I reckon you could get #5 or 6 with that deal. Doubt NM or WC bite. GWS have sights on Cadman I reckon. * wouldn’t trade with us. Scott will want to use it also. Sheezel could easily drop. 1. Ashcroft (bid), Tsatas, Busslinger, Cadman, Wardlaw, Sheezel is how I could see it going. WC like Busslinger. Wardlaw drops I reckon. Sheezel could be there.