Recommitted Mitch Georgiades - Signs on for another 4 years

[Strapping Young Lad]

I’m reliably informed he’s re-signed with Port.

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

One of these players is not like the other.

OK.

What year did Gray injure his knee? How many years into his career?

We can all ask these basic questions.

You, or I, dont know whats ahead of Mitch.

In 2012 you didn't know who Gray was.

 

[The 747]

OK.

What year did Gray injure his knee? How many years into his career?

We can all ask these basic questions.

You, or I, dont know whats ahead of Mitch.

In 2012 you didn't know who Gray was.

I'm happy to predict Mitch won't be as good as Robbie Gray.

 

[d-mac3276]

Charlie Curnow did his ACL twice and is now the best player in footy.

Mediocs and Surgeons can work wonders these days.

Spoken like a true Carlton supporter

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Spoken like a true Carlton supporter

Name me a better player in footy right now? Go on

 

[The 747]

Name me a better player in footy right now? Go on

Toby Greene
Bontempelli
Daicos

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

I'm happy to predict Mitch won't be as good as Robbie Gray.

good on ya

 

[Caligo]

OK.

What year did Gray injure his knee? How many years into his career?

We can all ask these basic questions.

You, or I, dont know whats ahead of Mitch.

In 2012 you didn't know who Gray was.

No. MG has played more than enough games to prove that if he had the footy IQ of RG he would have shown it by now. He is a hugely athletic under sized key forward who may have lost the one thing that made him special. And that is before you take into account his kicking issues.

 

[d-mac3276]

Name me a better player in footy right now? Go on

Jeremy Cameron

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

No. MG has played more than enough games to prove that if he had the footy IQ of RG he would have shown it by now. He is a hugely athletic under sized key forward who may have lost the one thing that made him special. And that is before you take into account his kicking issues.

This answer is why I don't often post on this forum.

When did I compare his skills/footy IQ to Grays?

I commented on an injury and that is all. I'm a port fan so mentioned a port player with similar to compare with outcomes with athleticisms. Thats all! ffs.

I'm done. have fun.

 

[Caligo]

This answer is why I don't often post on this forum.

When did I compare his skills/footy IQ to Grays?

I commented on an injury and that is all. I'm a port fan so mentioned a port player with similar to compare with outcomes with athleticisms. Thats all! ffs.

I'm done. have fun.

RG succeeded after an ACL that reduced his agility because he has other attributes to fall back on (mostly his nous). MG hasn't shown any of that. The comparison is ludicrous.

There are purely athletic guys who have recovered from an ACL and were not physically impeded at all. But they are incredibly rare, and I am not sure I could even name one currently playing AFL.

Maybe Curnow at a stretch? Maybe.

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

RG succeeded after an ACL that reduced his agility because he has other attributes to fall back on (mostly his nous). MG hasn't shown any of that. The comparison is ludicrous.

There are purely athletic guys who have recovered from an ACL and were not physically impeded at all. But they are incredibly rare, and I am not sure I could even name one currently playing AFL.

Maybe Curnow at a stretch? Maybe.

You are a moron. Did you not read my last post?

 

[Caligo]

You are a moron. Did you not read my last post?

I read your inane post comparing Robbie Gray to Mitch Georgiades, and then tried in vain across multiple posts to explain why that comparison is not legitimate. Clearly, I failed.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Toby Greene
Bontempelli
Daicos

Well each to their own.

I think Petracca is better than all 3 of them myself.

 

[The 747]

Well each to their own.

I think Petracca is better than all 3 of them myself.

Yeah arguable. Depends over what time period you are measuring.

 

[Caligo]

Well each to their own.

I think Petracca is better than all 3 of them myself.

They are certainly all in a band of elite players. Hard to separate. Probably you just do it based on form.

For me J Cameron is the best player in the league, but his recent form isn't the best. But everyone on that list is a fair call.

 

[The 747]

You are a moron. Did you not read my last post?

No need for a personal attack mate; this is a discussion on a forum.

 

[HinkleysHeroes]

I read your inane post comparing Robbie Gray to Mitch Georgiades, and then tried in vain across multiple posts to explain why that comparison is not legitimate. Clearly, I failed.

Not once did I compare their career or skill.

Have a nice night

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Yeah arguable. Depends over what time period you are measuring.

Just this season, not overall careers.

 

[Caligo]

Just this season, not overall careers.

First half Cameron, second half could be any of the people listed. Maybe Greene?

But Petracca absolutely blew a grand final apart. That can't be underrated.

 

[Burtman]

Charlie Curnow did his ACL twice and is now the best player in footy.

Mediocs and Surgeons can work wonders these days.

Not only did curnow not do two acl’s, he didn’t even do one.

 

[Gee Class Loco]

Not only did curnow not do two acl’s, he didn’t even do one.

Correct it was knee caps both times.
Some blokes claim they know a thing or two but know sweet Fresh Apples.
ACL’s Pffttt…

 

[Gee Class Loco]

Charlie Curnow did his ACL twice and is now the best player in footy.

Mediocs and Surgeons can work wonders these days.

LOL No…
He did zero ACLs
He cracked his knee cap… twice.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

LOL No…
He did zero ACLs
He cracked his knee cap… twice.

Whatever. He is still the 2 time Coleman Medalist and biggest superstar in the AFL these days.

 

[Caligo]

Whatever. He is still the 2 time Coleman Medalist and biggest superstar in the AFL these days.

Sure, but he isn't applicable to questions about agility after an ACL. Which is the entire point of this discussion.