Traded Sam Petrevski-Seton [Traded to West Coast as part of three way trade for Pick 52]

[FreeAgent1]

 

[Ambrosia]

Is a one touch player who can make good decisions in traffic but doesn’t really have any other AFL attributes from what I’ve seen.

Less athletic Narkle is how I would describe him.

 

[Bostonian]

Brander -> Geelong
Constable -> Carlton
SPS -> West Coast

Add draft picks in to balance as needed

No more Geelong off casts please.

We've had enough of them to last a lifetime lately.

 

[Bostonian]

Is a one touch player who can make good decisions in traffic but doesn’t really have any other AFL attributes from what I’ve seen.

Less athletic Narkle is how I would describe him.

Nah, Narkle isn't afraid to get hit in a contest.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Brander -> Geelong
Constable -> Carlton
SPS -> West Coast

Add draft picks in to balance as needed

Im not sure if carlton will want another inside mid with hewett coming. Whats probably more likely is we trade a R3 or so pick for brander which then gets forwarded to carlton for SPS (minor draft pick swaps to balance if needed). Id expect we ask about brander again especially if kreuger goes.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

No more Geelong off casts please.

We've had enough of them to last a lifetime lately.

To be fair fogarty is ok..but the rest of them..not much.

 

[Bostonian]

To be fair fogarty is ok..but the rest of them..not much.

To be fair he's pretty average.

His best isn't bad, his worst is bad.

He just has no consistency in his game and that is at least the start of what's required to be considered best 22.

 

[HBFlanker]

Pick 49 seems about right

 

[Kings of Lygon]

Brander -> Geelong
Constable -> Carlton
SPS -> West Coast

Add draft picks in to balance as needed

Highly doubt Carlton would have any interest in Constable. Brander would make more sense as a swingman/backup big who still has scope for improvement, no need to include Geelong.

 

[mezaire]

Cartlon
Give: 6, SPS
Get: Cerra

Freo
Give: Cerra
Get: 6, Clark

Geelong
Give: Clark
Get: Brander

West Coast
Give: Brander
Get: SPS

Plus and exchange of 3rd/4th round picks where needed

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Cartlon
Give: 6, SPS
Get: Cerra

Freo
Give: Cerra
Get: 6, Clark

Geelong
Give: Clark
Get: Brander

West Coast
Give: Brander
Get: SPS

Plus and exchange of 3rd/4th round picks where needed

We would want more than brander for a contracted clark and realistically cerra is worth more than 6 and SPS.

Add in carltons R2, send that to geelong, and geelongs R3 back to carlton (possibly late pick swaps to freo also if needed) and its more equitable imo.

 

[TENACIOUS]

SPS for Brander straight swap seems fair and would be beneficial for both teams...
We don't want anymore Geelong players, unless it's SDK...

 

[Obeanie1]

Keep hearing straight swap talk but why the fu** would Carlton want Brander? Wouldn't start for them at either end.

Because Plowman is really, really bad in defense and Brander can swing either end. Marchbank isnt much better. Both 193 cm 3rd tall defenders.

In another 12 months McGovern will be shown the door as well, a 3rd tall forward.

So that's 3 players at the Blues Brander could take spots off.

 

[schmuttt]

How do these journos still not know how trades work? A 2nd round pick LOL

 

[Obeanie1]

View attachment 1242979

How do these journos still not know how trades work? A 2nd round pick LOL

Media in trade period.....................

 

[Suma Magic]

If you align his trade value with what he will be getting paid, then he is worth not much.

 

[Suma Magic]

If it was done on free agency compensation, the blues would get a pick in the mid 40s.

 

[Kwality]

To be fair he's pretty average.

His best isn't bad, his worst is bad.

He just has no consistency in his game and that is at least the start of what's required to be considered best 22.

Sad to say, he'd fit the Eagles of the last half of 2021.

 

[Taylor]

I think West Coast will get a steal playing him as a midfielder.

 

[ubiquitous226]

View attachment 1242979

How do these journos still not know how trades work? A 2nd round pick LOL

Yeah that's crazy.

I guess to give him a tiny bit of credit he acknowledged 10 was too high..

Nah he's still crazy.

 

[Neale4brownlow]

Yeah that's crazy.

I guess to give him a tiny bit of credit he acknowledged 10 was too high..

Nah he's still crazy.

Anyone who feels the need to still acknowledge 10 is too high is not worth their salt.

 

[DragoDelph]

Anyone who mentions WC first round picks at all is an idiot.
They can’t trade this years or next years, without bringing in a replacement.

 

[FilthyRon]

Doubt WC would do it but SPS and 25 for 29 and 35

 

[Wally Walpamur]

Doubt WC would do it but SPS and 25 for 29 and 35

Why not keep 25 and jusy do SPS for 35?

 

[Glek]

Doubt WC would do it but SPS and 25 for 29 and 35

I think that might work and could be a route to confirm Cerra with 6 29 35 values him around 2 - Freo than can split 6 or 8 and bundle 29 & 35 to get the right WA kids. Just not sure Blues would do it.

 

[La Dispute]

View attachment 1242979

How do these journos still not know how trades work? A 2nd round pick LOL

Club X sees midfielder as midfielder.

Great stuff.