Free Agency Tom Doedee [to Brisbane as RFA]

[Elixuh]

FA compensation should take order of priority over Norths welfare. Assume pick 19 statement is correct.

 

[Red Bull]

Breaking :

End of first round compensation pick to the WWE for … Doink the Clown

 

[Testekill]

Adelaide will take pick 19 for a player with no knees that has always relied on his mobility and run laughing.

Real cool that the AFL aren't taking the new CBA agreement into consideration.

 

[Testekill]

This is definitely the year you want to lose a free agent. AFL being super generous.

The compensation formula isn't taking the new changes to the CBA and the increase in salaries into account. So yes, perfect time to lose a free agent where more money is being thrown about and the AFL hasn't adjusted yet.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

If Doedee is worth pick 19 im asking for pick 3 and 4 if im North for McKay

Why, as Doedee is the better player.

But I'm sure the AFL considered the goal umpire loading...

 

[Bearded Clam]

Having a compo system is fine but player salaries need to be made public and also the system for how picks are handed out needs to be clear. We can’t have this stupid guessing game

The AFL dont want to do that though..

If the clubs know the formula and everyone knows the salary everyone else is on then the clubs can then attempt to rort the system…

 

[YoungsterPA]

The AFL dont want to do that though..

If the clubs know the formula and everyone knows the salary everyone else is on then the clubs can then attempt to rort the system…

Clubs already rort it however they can

 

[Bearded Clam]

Clubs already rort it however they can

They do.. but they still play a guessing game..

If they actually knew the exact formula and the wages of every player in the comp at that moment..

Then they wouldnt need to guess..

 

[Checksider]

Adelaide will take pick 19 for a player with no knees that has always relied on his mobility and run laughing.

Real cool that the AFL aren't taking the new CBA agreement into consideration.

They didn’t do it for us, they want to get North pick 3.

 

[Testekill]

They didn’t do it for us, they want to get North pick 3.

It's a byproduct that the Crows are more than happy to take as a happy accident.

 

[Checksider]

It's a byproduct that the Crows are more than happy to take as a happy accident.

Just happy to not be getting ****ed by the league for a change. Being accidental bystanding benefactors is a bonus.

Other clubs will also benefit.

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Why, as Doedee is the better player.

But I'm sure the AFL considered the goal umpire loading...

Contract amount and length

Talent has zero to do with compensation and thats been well established

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Just happy to not be getting ****ed by the league for a change. Being accidental bystanding benefactors is a bonus.

Other clubs will also benefit.

Yeah you do definetly deserve it really

 

[kreuze_missile]

Restricted free agency compensation has to go.

ASAP.

What a ******* joke.

 

[PeterSalt]

Restricted free agency compensation has to go.

ASAP.

What a ******* joke.

Remember when Geelong had a really poor draft hand in 2017, and then they let Steven Motlop go to Port via free agency?

And then Geelong took that pick, pick 19, and offered it up to GC for Gary Ablett Jnr

Now that was a joke

 

[rye]

an early to mid second is about what doedee would be worth in a trade so i dont see why people are upset about this

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

If Doedee is worth pick 19 im asking for pick 3 and 4 if im North for McKay

What?

Doedee is better than McKay

 

[Dirty Bird]

It's very much based on net ins and outs. And I think only goes as high as 3rd or 4th round?? Need an expert like AmericanCrow , Southerntakeover or Dirty Bird

NFL's is done a year later and takes into account ins and outs over the previous season, and the earliest draft pick they hand out is an end of 3rd round pick (7rd draft)

 

[ABAB]

"towards $700,000 on a four-year deal with a trigger for a fifth" with a Jon Ralph caveat.

So band 2, why is everyone surprise?

 

[Books]

The AFL dont want to do that though..

If the clubs know the formula and everyone knows the salary everyone else is on then the clubs can then attempt to rort the system…

Correct.
The AFL prefer to rort the system themselves, to get the outcomes they want.

 

[cotter101]

Crows get a good pick, we get a very good player.

That is assuming our medical team can get him right after the ACL’s. Happy to back them in.

 

[TW Sherrin]

#SAbias

 

[Wolff]

#SAbias

Freeee kick Daicos!

 

[Jarman3]

Crows get a good pick, we get a very good player.

That is assuming our medical team can get him right after the ACL’s. Happy to back them in.

I hope for your sake and Tom's that they're able to, but I have my doubts that we'll ever see his best again. 2 ACL's is one thing if they're on the same knee, but having both knees done seems to be much harder to get back from in terms of getting back to the same level as pre-injury. That's not to say he'll be complete dud or anything, just that he may not get to a level of performance to justify the reported contract.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

#SAbias

How so?