Autopsy Wayne Carey: "Jack > Buddy"

[Brad Goodman]

Loving themselves sick aren't they

 

[MightyTiger]

Hawkins is much better. Is a better skilled player and has had the better career to date.

No he hasn't. And no he isn't, Jack is a far better footballer then what Hawkins is.

 

[MightyTiger]

This is the same Jack Riewoldt that did not even kick 40 goals this year, right???

Kicked 54 I believe. Not bad for a forward who played a selfless role and a lone hand up forward as the key target.

 

[BEEG]

Ablett>Carey>Dunstall>Hudson>>>>>>>>>>>>Buddy>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Kennedy>>>Hawkins>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Riewoldt

Riewoldt >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hawkins

 

[vide0n]

Don't really understand the point of these kind of comparisons

 

[MightyTiger]

I doubt Jack has beaten Buddy in any goal kicking tally over the course of their careers.

How did Jack win two Coleman's then bud? Did Buddy have a hiatus or something from football?

 

[Benny78]

Riewoldt >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hawkins

Nice argument lol

Hawkins rated better in like every aspect.

 

[Captain_Bender]

Hawkins is much better. Is a better skilled player and has had the better career to date.

You kidding mate Jack Riewoldt >>> daylight >>> Tom Hawkins Geelong supporters and their inferiority complex towards Richmond are hilarious

 

[Scotland]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...s/news-story/aa9fc82eb7e8e539191d0df5d4d53101

Carey said: “Just having a look at Sam Mitchell, I want to ask you a question, would he get a game at any other club?"

This was in 2015, when Sam Mitchell came 3rd in the B&F and made the AA side. He then won the B&F in 2016.

Wouldn't put too much stock in what Wayne Carey thinks.

 

[Nightrain]

He's not even the best Reiwoldt.

Bring on trade period already.

For all the flack Pies supporters get for being the worse in the league I don't remember this level of arrogance coming from the premier's supporters in 2010 or after any flag for that matter. In fact, was at both gfs in 2010 and 2011 and Pies supporters handled themselves very well after winning one and losing one.

 

[Benny78]

You kidding mate Jack Riewoldt >>> daylight >>> Tom Hawkins Geelong supporters and their inferiority complex towards Richmond are hilarious

Surely you mean Nick yeah? LOL

 

[Scotland]

FWIW most people would rate Jack Riewoldt about the 5th or 6th best key forward in the comp.

 

[RUNVS]

How did Jack win two Coleman's then bud? Did Buddy have a hiatus or something from football?

DId he? Didn't even realise. To me Jack has always been a 40 to 50 goals a season sort of forward.

 

[BEEG]

Nice argument lol

Hawkins rated better in like every aspect.

Played in much better teams, Riewoldt is the better forward hands down.

 

[Captain_Bender]

Surely you mean Nick yeah? LOL

Jack Riewoldt has kicked almost 100 more goals than Hawkins has and that's with Riewoldt playing in bad teams for most of his career while Hawkins was spuding it up in one of the greatest teams ever Jack Riewoldt has won 2 Coleman medals how many has Hawkins won?

 

[Engimal v3]

I'd be pretty embarrassed to have made this thread. Buddy is much better, and it's not close.

 

[BEEG]

Jack Riewoldt has kicked almost 100 more goals than Hawkins has and that's with Riewoldt playing in bad teams for most of his career while Hawkins was spuding it up in one of the greatest teams ever Jack Riewoldt has won 2 Coleman medals how many has Hawkins won?

Hawkins has sat in the square most of his career as well.

 

[Benny78]

Played in much better teams, Riewoldt is the better forward hands down.

* I don't care what Collingwood have to say, ok? Anyway riewoldt is a choker and a poor kick. Much like Caddy except Riewoldt used to kick bags years ago however is a lot like Caddy now.

Hawkins is a champ who scares opposition coaches, outshines Riewoldt in accolades and match day performances. No club in their right mind would trade for Riewoldt before Hawkins.

 

[BEEG]

**** I don't care what Collingwood have to say, ok? Anyway riewoldt is a choker and a poor kick. Much like Caddy except Riewoldt used to kick bags years ago however is a lot like Caddy now.

Hawkins is a champ who scares opposition coaches, outshines Riewoldt in accolades and match day performances. No club in their right mind would trade for Riewoldt before Hawkins.

 

[robertg22]

**** I don't care what Collingwood have to say, ok? Anyway riewoldt is a choker and a poor kick. Much like Caddy except Riewoldt used to kick bags years ago however is a lot like Caddy now.

Hawkins is a champ who scares opposition coaches, outshines Riewoldt in accolades and match day performances. No club in their right mind would trade for Riewoldt before Hawkins.

So many tears..

Riewoldt is better than Hawkins. Hawkins is about on the Travis Cloke level

 

[market]

Reckon Jack is great and played a great GF. But Budwah is a freak, one of the greatest players ever, certainly in past 10 years. As for Carey, he's trying too hard again to be controversial. (if he did say this)

 

[Bomber_Dan]

Ablett>Carey>Dunstall>Hudson>>>>>>>>>>>>Buddy>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Kennedy>>>Hawkins>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Riewoldt

Hawkins? Bahahahaha

 

[StillAtLarge]

**** I don't care what Collingwood have to say, ok? Anyway riewoldt is a choker and a poor kick. Much like Caddy except Riewoldt used to kick bags years ago however is a lot like Caddy now.

Hawkins is a champ who scares opposition coaches, outshines Riewoldt in accolades and match day performances. No club in their right mind would trade for Riewoldt before Hawkins.

Hawkins is far from a clutch kick. Aside from the 2012 post siren effort he has been unreliable and was truly awful this finals series

 

[BEEG]

So many tears..

Riewoldt is better than Hawkins. Hawkins is about on the Travis Cloke level

Hawkins is one of the more overrated forwards of this era, does absolutely nothing apart from give dumb free kicks away, how Cat fans can even compare him to Riewoldt is laughable.

 

[Tigers123]

**** I don't care what Collingwood have to say, ok? Anyway riewoldt is a choker and a poor kick. Much like Caddy except Riewoldt used to kick bags years ago however is a lot like Caddy now.

Hawkins is a champ who scares opposition coaches, outshines Riewoldt in accolades and match day performances. No club in their right mind would trade for Riewoldt before Hawkins.

Hawkins: 1x AA 0 Colemans
Riewoldt: 2x AA 2 Colemans

Jack >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hawkins
Hawkins is the least versatile key forward possible and is crap