The Pied Piper
Senior List
- Sep 24, 2014
- 239
- 219
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
We need an impact player like him.
Let's welcome him to the club he was destined to play for.
Let's welcome him to the club he was destined to play for.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Wouldn't go that far. Destiny is a big statementWe need an impact player like him.
Let's welcome him to the club he was destined to play for.
How much impact do you expect a player who averages less than 13 touches and a goal a game make? We may as well just keep persisting with Blair...We need an impact player like him.
Let's welcome him to the club he was destined to play for.
WHE is not the answer. I'd rather boomer HarveyHow much impact do you expect a player who averages less than 13 touches and a goal a game make? We may as well just keep persisting with Blair...
He's just not worth a high pick imo. If we can snag him second rounder then good. But not a first rounderI like the idea of bringing in a classy half forward as I feel it's one of our biggest list needs, but honestly if a first rounder is the price to pay for WHE I would rather go to the draft with that pick should we somehow acquire it. There are as many question marks on WHE as there are on a draftee because of his minimal AFL output and injuries.
I expect other clubs would think similarly. The only club I can see offering a late first rounder for WHE Is Hawthorn because of their emphasis on outside skill and because they will probably finish top 4 (hopefully we have a say in that but I don't expect we will win on Sunday). I think ultimately if he nominates us we will get him for whatever we get for Witts, if not for Witts himself should GWS be interested.
He'd only need 1 touch a game to have more impact than Blair / witches hat / garden knome, take your pick. Blair is not dangerous to the opposition, no threat.How much impact do you expect a player who averages less than 13 touches and a goal a game make? We may as well just keep persisting with Blair...
We can't get everyone. But your right. Blair is not effective enough for a small forwardHe'd only need 1 touch a game to have more impact than Blair / witches hat / garden knome, take your pick. Blair is not dangerous to the opposition, no threat.
With Blair's existence, we've foregone Kennedy, and arguably overlooked Caleb Daniel.
HE would not replace Blair anyway, different types.
I'd rather get a 'lazy' Jarrod Pickett to replace Blair - he'd have more toe, more skill, kick more goals, stick more tackles, fumble less. By all reports he'd turned the corner with his work ethic earlier in the season before inj'd. We need more dangerous players, & Pickett is that also. Let's get him as well if we can.
Why does Paul buhagiar come up in the grey box of a reply when you are Pablo Disco Bar?
Anti-Blair rants aside, WHE is garbage. He's been in the system for 5 years with nothing to show for it, and for some reason some people like yourself still rate him as some kind of amazing impact player. He's not Cyril Rioli who can light a game up with 10 touches on a frequent basis. He's a guy who's had less than a handful of decent games, a ton of below average ones, has one of the worst DE% in the league and is injury prone to boot.He'd only need 1 touch a game to have more impact than Blair / witches hat / garden knome, take your pick. Blair is not dangerous to the opposition, no threat.
With Blair's existence, we've foregone Kennedy, and arguably overlooked Caleb Daniel.
HE would not replace Blair anyway, different types.
I'd rather get a 'lazy' Jarrod Pickett to replace Blair - he'd have more toe, more skill, kick more goals, stick more tackles, fumble less. By all reports he'd turned the corner with his work ethic earlier in the season before inj'd. We need more dangerous players, & Pickett is that also. Let's get him as well if we can.
Krueger?First thing which crossed my mind was "someone has stolen his laptop and is posting on his account"
Anti-Blair rants aside, WHE is garbage. He's been in the system for 5 years with nothing to show for it, and for some reason some people like yourself still rate him as some kind of amazing impact player. He's not Cyril Rioli who can light a game up with 10 touches on a frequent basis. He's a guy who's had less than a handful of decent games, a ton of below average ones, has one of the worst DE% in the league and is injury prone to boot.
I'd give Pickett a go as he hasn't had a decent run at it and is only second year, but WHE is close to worthless as it stands. Giving up anything worthwhile for him stinks of J O'Rourke MK II.
Did we trade our 2017 First Round? no.. I don't think we did.
Oath.Posting questions and answering them as well now? To sharp for me Rup!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
We obviously could do with a few more classy players in our side, but (just for the record) Fremantle (with 9), Port Adelaide (8) and Gold Coast (7) were the clubs with the most indigenous players on their list in 2016.If we can't get him lets get some classy Aboriginal players in the forward, midfield and back line.
We need some desperately.
Varcoe can't do it all by himself.
If we can't get him lets get some classy Aboriginal players in the forward, midfield and back line.
We need some desperately.
Varcoe can't do it all by himself.
Why don't we get both?WHE is not the answer. I'd rather boomer Harvey
Hoskin Elliott would be good for the future team going forward to play with the likes of Treloar Adams and Aish.
Harvey would be good for 2017 to help raise our spirits under Buckley.
You need about 8 midfeilders in todays footy the game is just a bunch of players following the ball around, he would fit in to our 8 man midfeild.Where would he play though? Our midfield is already stacked, especially if we get WHE.
Stick him in the forward line behind Cox and hope he kicks a bag you reckon?
Not to be pedantic but wasn't the past few premiership gaps
20 years, 32 years, 5 years, 17 years, back to back, 5 years, four in a row, 8 years, 2 years, 7 years, 7 years, back to back, and 6 years.
You know I was only going tongue in cheek.