Analysis Have Carlton or Richmond constructed the better pool of young assets?

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Marcel Proust

"Oohh WADA ooga booga" {Jul 11 2013}
Sep 6, 2018
29,608
38,560
#BigBigSound
AFL Club
Richmond
Carlton are in the media spotlight currently but the fact remains they have a good young list; which should be climbing the ladder one year sooner or later. Nathan Brown nominated 13 carlton all Australians to be.

How does Richmond compare to this vast talent pool?

Stack v Walsh.
RCD v Stocker.
Balta v Curnow
CCJ v McKay
Dow v Ross
OBrien v Higgins
Weitering v Garthwaite

etc.

Outside of the following list of draftees of the last four/five draft periods - carlton have also acquired some player in this age bracket via trades in the spirit of a fair comparison.


Carlton

upcoming draft draft picks. nominal order as of round 10
Carlton: 12, 37, 48, 70, 84

(prior to potential AFL-Carlton priority draft picks)


National 1 1 Sam Walsh
National 1 19 Liam Stocker
National 4 66 Finbar O'Dwyer
National 5 70 Ben Silvagni F
Rookie 1 1 Hugh Goddard
Rookie 2 19 Tomas Bugg


National 1 3 Paddy Dow
National 1 10 Lochie O'Brien
National 2 30 Tom De Koning
National 4 70 Angus Schumacher
National 5 78 Jarrod Garlett


National 1 6 Sam Petrevski-Seton
National 2 27 Zac Fisher
National 3 47 Harrison Macreadie
National 4 59 Cameron Polson
National 4 61 Tom Williamson
National 4 65 Pat Kerr
Rookie 1 5 Kym LeBois
Rookie 2 23 Alex Silvagni


National 1 1 Jacob Weitering
National 1 10 Harry McKay
National 1 12 Charlie Curnow
National 1 23 David Cuningham
National 4 53 Jack Silvagni


2014: draft fail; Blaine Boekhorst, Dillon Viojo-Rainbow


Richmond


upcoming draft draft picks. nominal order as of round 10
Richmond: 15, 33, 38, 69, 72


National 1 20 Riley Collier-Dawkins
National 2 43 Jack Ross
National 4 58 Fraser Turner
National 4 62 Luke English
Rookie 1 16 Jake Aarts
Rookie 2 32 Jacob Townsend
Rookie 3 45 Mabior Chol


National 1 17 Jack Higgins
National 2 20 Callum Coleman-Jones
National 2 25 Noah Balta
National 2 34 Patrick Naish
National 4 63 Ben Miller
Rookie 1 18 Liam Baker


National 2 29 Shai Bolton
National 3 53 Jack Graham
National 5 72 Ryan Garthwaite
Rookie 1 6 Tyson Stengle Adelaide [trade]


National 1 15 Daniel Rioli
National 3 50 Oleg Markov
National 5 67 Nathan Broad
Rookie 1 12 Callum Moore



2014: draft pass; Kane Lambert, Jason Castagna, Ivan Soldo, Connor Menadue, Daniel Butler, Jayden Short, Corey Ellis [trade suns]


Will the Tigers be able to keep tabs on Carlton in future years as they go charging up the ladder? Or is the hoarding of talent at the blues too great a gap to overcome?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back