Traded Jarryd Lyons [traded to Gold Coast with pick 71 for picks 43 and 67]

[Daniltchenko You Beauty]

Adelaide lack midfield depth, let solid midfielder go. Very strange.

 

[Scotty_222]

Lyons to GC could help get the O'meara deal going.

possibly

 

[Vikingblood]

Adelaide lack midfield depth, let solid midfielder go. Very strange.

We don't lack midfield depth at all, we just lack another A grader to assist Sloane. We need quality not quantity as was shown when we played the top sides this year. Lyons is a good player, just not a huge upside for him.

 

[DaveLister]

We don't lack midfield depth at all, we just lack another A grader to assist Sloane. We need quality not quantity as was shown when we played the top sides this year. Lyons is a good player, just not a huge upside for him.

Adelaide's midfield depth wasn't really tested this year. Hard to say if it's good or bad

 

[Ants]

Lyons to GC could help get the O'meara deal going.

How? The only currency Hawthorn has is #48. GCS can simply trade #44 to Adelaide for Lyons.

I suppose if Adelaide will take a Hartung type for Lyons, maybe. But would they do that? Surely this is simply a matter of GCS trading directly with Adelaide. They've got more picks than they need anyway.

 

[lkg04]

Hawthorn,adelaide,carlton and gc,possibly do a trade involving lyons,Gibbs and o'meara,swap of picks possibly?.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

 

[NeutralFan]

What I was thinking Ikg, 4 way trade

 

[Tyler Hodges]

I wonder if pick 10 is enough for Gibbs? If so a 3 way which would see;
- Pick 10 and 48/ Schoenmakers go to Adelaide
- Pick 13 and Lyons go to GC
- Omeara to hawthorn
- Crows use pick 10 for Gibbs

 

[mikeythemoocow]

I wonder if pick 10 is enough for Gibbs?

Doubt it, doubt crows do 3 spot upgrade for Lyon either

Nobody cares about 48

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Doubt it, doubt crows do 3 spot upgrade for Lyon either

Depends, if there's a player Blues think they can get for 10 but not 13 it could be something to consider.

 

[Vikingblood]

Adelaide's midfield depth wasn't really tested this year. Hard to say if it's good or bad

Ellis-Yolmen ready to step up. Grigg, Wigg, Milera all can run through the mid at a strong level. Also Riley Knight back fro injury.

 

[gillo94]

I wonder if pick 10 is enough for Gibbs? If so a 3 way which would see;
- Pick 10 and 48 go to Adelaide
- Pick 13 and Lyons go to GC
- Omeara to hawthorn
- Crows use pick 10 for Gibbs

I'm thinking Lyons to Suns will make Gibbs trade go faster to Crows

Suns trade Pick 26 to Crows for Lyons
Then
Gibbs and 58 for
Picks 13 and 26
This way Crows end up with a Third Round Pick

 

[NeutralFan]

Surprised Carlton turned down the Pick 13 + Atkins deal in the first place, he's a GUN. They could do that but Pick 10 instead of 13, making it sound like almost a steal.

 

[the universal]

Lyons is a very solid pick up for the Suns, wish him all the best.

Adelaide's midfield depth wasn't really tested this year. Hard to say if it's good or bad

One of the main issues has been selection/playing underperforming seniors so we can't really know for sure.

 

[Tyler Hodges]

I'm thinking Lyons to Suns will make Gibbs trade go faster to Crows

Suns trade Pick 26 to Crows for Lyons
Then
Gibbs and 58 for
Picks 13 and 26
This way Crows end up with a Third Round Pick

The only reason I suggest a three way is that it's a last chance for GC and Hawthorn to save face without backing down on demands, there won't be another best 22 player announce he wants a GC trade with 24 hours left I think it's not coincidental Lyons announces he wants to go to GC an hour after Cochranes comments.

 

[Scotty_222]

I wonder if pick 10 is enough for Gibbs? If so a 3 way which would see;
- Pick 10 and 48/ Schoenmakers go to Adelaide
- Pick 13 and Lyons go to GC
- Omeara to hawthorn
- Crows use pick 10 for Gibbs

So pick 10 isn't enough so we now go further back in the draft.. no

 

[Tyler Hodges]

So pick 10 isn't enough so we now go further back in the draft.. no

You'll be getting a first round and best 22 player you want as a last gasp before getting 0 return on JOM. Regardless I'm talking about Lyons please save the arguments for the JOM thread I'm spitballing ideas here, cheers.

 

[Scotty_222]

There is no arguing. You threw out an idea and I cut it down.. we wanted 10 and 14, why would we 13 and Lyons. Carlton wouldn't take that with Gibbs, why would we

 

[Tyler Hodges]

There is no arguing. You through out an idea and I cut it down.. we wanted 10 and 14, why would we 13 and Lyons. Carlton wouldn't take that with Gibbs, why would we

We can't get you two first rounds, it's not even being bias and stubborn I mean it literally can't be done so come up with some suggestions. Stop being rude, cheers.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

We can't get you two first rounds, it's not even being bias and stubborn I mean it literally can't be done so come up with some suggestions. Stop being rude, cheers.

You could have - you prioritised Tom Mitchell.

 

[Scotty_222]

We can't get you two first rounds, it's not even being bias and stubborn I mean it literally can't be done so come up with some suggestions. Stop being rude, cheers.

I'm not being rude? Im just responding to you're post. What have I said that you didn't like

 

[Tyler Hodges]

You could have - you prioritised Tom Mitchell.

Yep, and that's done and dusted. So both sides can try their best to get this deal done with what we have or they both get nothing, which is fine but both clubs are negotiating, got any suggestions or are we still gonna live in the past?

 

[Scotty_222]

Yep, and that's done and dusted. So both sides can try their best to get this deal done with what we have or they both get nothing, which is fine but both clubs are negotiating, got any suggestions or are we still gonna live in the past?

I think it's too late to do anything..

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Yep, and that's done and dusted. So both sides can try their best to get this deal done with what we have or they both get nothing, which is fine but both clubs are negotiating, got any suggestions or are we still gonna live in the past?

Well Lyons looks like he might be Hawks saviour - other than that walk away.

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Well Lyons looks like he might be Hawks saviour - other than that walk away.

Yeah I'm trying to figure out his worth, a swap of 13 to 10 and perhaps Schoenmakers, or maybe Whitecross.