How so? At full flight Doedee the far better player.
Free Agency Tom Doedee [to Brisbane as RFA]
- Thread starter The Nostradamus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I agree, end of first round should be the max compensation and everything lower scaled down accordingly.
I would guess teams are pricing in the expected increases to the CBA and salary cap when making offers this offseason. Meanwhile the AFL hasn't updated their compensation mechanism to account for this, making it a very good seller's market for free agents.
- Jul 13, 2015
- 36,540
- 40,733
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
How much is his contract ?
- Aug 16, 2010
- 10,062
- 6,947
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Massive win for the Crom
- Mar 19, 2020
- 12,535
- 39,034
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Based on contract given mostly. Doedee isnt on 4 mill over the life of his contract etc
Oh no your ridiculous hand out package has been bumped. Get over it, unbelievable
'Pre-agents' will soon be a thing of the past if the AFL FA compo ends up better than you can get in a trade anyway.
This is definitely the year you want to lose a free agent. AFL being super generous.
H00t
Premiership Player
- Sep 28, 2019
- 4,892
- 8,511
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Which upper member of AFL house has decided to give their young kid the of job handing out compensation?
A very generous kid at that.
A very generous kid at that.
The man’s done an acl in each leg and played 80 games, I can’t understand how pick 19 is given here, I rate Doedee but this is crazy
Reported somewhere as 4 years @ $700K
Brad Crouch was band 3 reported @$650K (with several incentive bonus - not included in FA calculations)
It's crazy that Doedee has done two ACLs and still played 11 more games to this point than McKay who's about to get pick 3.
Last edited:
It's just a trash system, we have seen time and time again that the current rules are awful and very rarely actually generate 'fair' compo.
"towards $700,000 on a four-year deal with a trigger for a fifth" with a Jon Ralph caveat.
Just as an example for those that think I'm being crazy:
Pick 1. H. Reid (WC)
Pick 2. Walter - North bid (GC)
Pick 3. Curtin (North)
Pick 4. McKercher - McKay compo (North)
Pick 5. Watson - trade with GC for Picks 11, 18 and Future 1st, for 5 and Future 2nd (Dogs)
Pick 6. Z. Duursma (Hawks)
Pick 7. E. Read - Melbourne bid (GC)
Pick 8. O'Sullivan (Melbourne)
Pick 9. N. Caddy (GWS)
Pick 10. Sanders (Geelong)
Pick 11. Rogers - Essendon bid (GC)
Pick 12. D. Wilson (Essendon)
Pick 13. Schoenmaker (Adelaide)
Pick 14. O. Murphy (whoever trades with GC to get this pick)
Pick 15. Windsor (Sydney)
Pick 16. A. Roberts (St Kilda)
Pick 17. J. Croft - Melbourne bid (Bulldogs)
Pick 18. A. Reid (Melbourne)
Pick 19. McCabe - North bid (Hawks)
Pick 20. Hardemann (North)
Pick 21. Leake (GWS)
Pick 22. DeMattia (Carlton)
Pick 23. Tholstrup (whoever trades with GC to get this pick)
Pick 24. C. Cleary - Collingwood bid (Sydney)
Pick 25. Zakostelsky - Collingwood
Pick 26. W. Graham - North bid (GC)
Pick 27. M. Edwards - (North, compo)
Pick 28. C. Edwards (Adelaide, compo)
Pick 29. Moir (Gresham, compo - not confirmed but still possible given the Doedee deal and rumoured Essendon offer)
End of 1st round
Pick 30. Start of second round.
Pick 1. H. Reid (WC)
Pick 2. Walter - North bid (GC)
Pick 3. Curtin (North)
Pick 4. McKercher - McKay compo (North)
Pick 5. Watson - trade with GC for Picks 11, 18 and Future 1st, for 5 and Future 2nd (Dogs)
Pick 6. Z. Duursma (Hawks)
Pick 7. E. Read - Melbourne bid (GC)
Pick 8. O'Sullivan (Melbourne)
Pick 9. N. Caddy (GWS)
Pick 10. Sanders (Geelong)
Pick 11. Rogers - Essendon bid (GC)
Pick 12. D. Wilson (Essendon)
Pick 13. Schoenmaker (Adelaide)
Pick 14. O. Murphy (whoever trades with GC to get this pick)
Pick 15. Windsor (Sydney)
Pick 16. A. Roberts (St Kilda)
Pick 17. J. Croft - Melbourne bid (Bulldogs)
Pick 18. A. Reid (Melbourne)
Pick 19. McCabe - North bid (Hawks)
Pick 20. Hardemann (North)
Pick 21. Leake (GWS)
Pick 22. DeMattia (Carlton)
Pick 23. Tholstrup (whoever trades with GC to get this pick)
Pick 24. C. Cleary - Collingwood bid (Sydney)
Pick 25. Zakostelsky - Collingwood
Pick 26. W. Graham - North bid (GC)
Pick 27. M. Edwards - (North, compo)
Pick 28. C. Edwards (Adelaide, compo)
Pick 29. Moir (Gresham, compo - not confirmed but still possible given the Doedee deal and rumoured Essendon offer)
End of 1st round
Pick 30. Start of second round.
Probably end up like 2020 where there were 26 picks in the first round.
Yeah our future second from North gonna be pick 35
Last edited:
dogs105
Sweet Kennels Proprietor
NFL does
dogs105
Sweet Kennels Proprietor
It's very much based on net ins and outs. And I think only goes as high as 3rd or 4th round?? Need an expert like AmericanCrow , Southerntakeover or Dirty Bird
Having a compo system is fine but player salaries need to be made public and also the system for how picks are handed out needs to be clear. We can’t have this stupid guessing game
Think it'll be worse, honestly.
