Traded Patrick Ryder traded to Port for picks 17 and 37

[Ambrosia]

How does anyone make a case for Melksham over Moore?

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pp-port-adelaide-power--andrew-moore

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pp-essendon-bombers--jake-melksham

Because careers go for more than one season and Moore has never done anything special.

 

[Ambrosia]

Butcher plus 16 is a fair trade I just don't think Essendon have any need for it. I have faith in Carlisle as a forward, he had more than just a good fortnight and you have to remember Essendon's ball movement was horrendous at times. Carlisle forward also allows him more freedom to be the second ruck which I think would work well if he got a liking for it. Especially if Bomber coaches I expect Carlisle and Daniher to start to work really well and that would leave Butcher just languishing in the reserves.

I can't believe how hard it is to find a player from a top 4 side in Port that fits in to the 7th places Bombers as a nice pick up alongside Ryder. You'd think there'd be one. I'm a Ben Newton fan but it's hard to say he's worth anything more than a pick 50 and that makes him pretty negligible in trade value.

http://www.aflplayerratings.com.au/Ratings/Player/116340/Ben-NEWTON

Carlisle does ruck better than Daniher but given he seems to regularly have back complaints I don't see him being used as a second ruck over Daniher.

 

[Schulzenfest]

He won't be playing for us next year, but I doubt he will be playing for Port either. GWS and GC could both compensate us properly and Ryder fits the needs of both, I suspect we are negotiating with both clubs and unless Port come up with something sensible he will end up at one of those two clubs.

How is it that there are so many Bombers supporters with no idea of how trading works?

GWS can offer you pick 1 and Jeremy Cameron if they want, but if Ryder (whose manager has already said he's 'locked in' at Port) doesn't agree to the trade, then it is totally and utterly irrelevant.

Easily get a trade done too. First round pick plus Matera, done.

HAHAHAHAHA! Pick 7 and Matera for a 27 year old ASADA affected Ryder? **** me. Sure you don't want Ablett thrown in too?

 

[fishardansin]

How is it that there are so many Bombers supporters with no idea of how trading works?

GWS can offer you pick 1 and Jeremy Cameron if they want, but if Ryder (whose manager has already said he's 'locked in' at Port) doesn't agree to the trade, then it is totally and utterly irrelevant.



HAHAHAHAHA! Pick 7 and Matera for a 27 year old ASADA affected Ryder? **** me. Sure you don't want Ablett thrown in too?

ASADA affected? Why trade for him then?

 

[hazard]

How is it that there are so many Bombers supporters with no idea of how trading works?

GWS can offer you pick 1 and Jeremy Cameron if they want, but if Ryder (whose manager has already said he's 'locked in' at Port) doesn't agree to the trade, then it is totally and utterly irrelevant.



HAHAHAHAHA! Pick 7 and Matera for a 27 year old ASADA affected Ryder? **** me. Sure you don't want Ablett thrown in too?

I doubt GC would agree to a straight swap Matera for Ryder, let alone throwing in a draft pick too.

One more preseason in all our young fellas and we're going to be favourites for the premiership in 2015 with or without Ryder. No point throwing everything at him.

 

[Jdawgz]

tim membrey rejected essendon because of the circumstances..you think our players want to join your club? just take the picks FFS!

 

[blueboy25]

I doubt GC would agree to a straight swap Matera for Ryder, let alone throwing in a draft pick too.

One more preseason in all our young fellas and we're going to be favourites for the premiership in 2015 with or without Ryder. No point throwing everything at him.

And Matera would have to agree to go there. WA boy whose father played for West Coast but for some reason he would want to move to Essendon where they aren't even sure who the coach is.

 

[scottjr]

Because careers go for more than one season and Moore has never done anything special.

Moore is building.... Melksham not so much.

 

[Astro Bomber]

Now GC telling port to ggf regarding Gorringe. Lols

 

[scottjr]

Now GC telling port to ggf regarding Gorringe. Lols

He's easy we take him next year for nothing after Suns put another years development into him.

Edit

 

[dlanod]

He's easy we take him next year for nothing after GWS put another years development into him.

What is it with people trying to get Gorringe off GWS?

 

[scottjr]

What is it with people trying to get Gorringe off GWS?

Oops

 

[marty36]

Butcher plus 16 is a fair trade I just don't think Essendon have any need for it. I have faith in Carlisle as a forward, he had more than just a good fortnight and you have to remember Essendon's ball movement was horrendous at times. Carlisle forward also allows him more freedom to be the second ruck which I think would work well if he got a liking for it. Especially if Bomber coaches I expect Carlisle and Daniher to start to work really well and that would leave Butcher just languishing in the reserves.

I can't believe how hard it is to find a player from a top 4 side in Port that fits in to the 7th places Bombers as a nice pick up alongside Ryder. You'd think there'd be one. I'm a Ben Newton fan but it's hard to say he's worth anything more than a pick 50 and that makes him pretty negligible in trade value.

http://www.aflplayerratings.com.au/Ratings/Player/116340/Ben-NEWTON

Hahahahahaha Butcher should be delisted if Essendon take him they have been seriously duped!

 

[Lance Uppercut]

How is it that there are so many Bombers supporters with no idea of how trading works?

GWS can offer you pick 1 and Jeremy Cameron if they want, but if Ryder (whose manager has already said he's 'locked in' at Port) doesn't agree to the trade, then it is totally and utterly irrelevant.

well he and his manager can be as "locked" as they want, but if Ess don't agree to the trade it doesn't happen, and Ryder either plays in red and black or sits out of footy for 2 years

 

[BrockBlitz]

well he and his manager can be as "locked" as they want, but if Ess don't agree to the trade it doesn't happen, and Ryder either plays in red and black or sits out of footy for 2 years

He might have to do that anyway....

 

[Lance Uppercut]

He might have to do that anyway....

not a chance

 

[Jars458]

He's easy we take him next year for nothing after Suns put another years development into him.

Edit

As long as you finish lower than them.....so you should be fine.

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Isn't Ryder contracted?
Don't know about this confidence that he's picked Port so that's that.
They'll still have to make a fair and reasonable offer or the trade just won't go ahead.
He'd be stuck at Essendon.
I wouldn't imagine Essendon would blink an eyelid either in their current mood.

 

[Big Fresh]

tim membrey rejected essendon because of the circumstances..you think our players want to join your club? just take the picks FFS!

Who said it was due to the drugs scandal? He's leaving Sydney due to lack of opportunities so it would make sense that he nominates a club where he's an automatic selection each week such as St Kilda.

 

[BrockBlitz]

Who said it was due to the drugs scandal? He's leaving Sydney due to lack of opportunities so it would make sense that he nominates a club where he's an automatic selection each week such as St Kilda.

I think it basically comes down to Goodes deciding to go around again.

 

[Asgardian]

Trade radio made it clear the Bombers people are dicks to deal with & that Ryder using the get-out clause is a very real option and would be supported by the Players association.

 

[Big Fresh]

Trade radio made it clear the Bombers people are dicks to deal with & that Ryder using the get-out clause is a very real option and would be supported by the Players association.

That's Damian Barrett and Terry Wallace, right?

 

[*PAF]

Hahahahahaha Butcher should be delisted if Essendon take him they have been seriously duped!

I disagree with delisting, but no club should be considering trading for him with a half decent pick atm.

 

[boncer34]

Trade radio made it clear the Bombers people are dicks to deal with & that Ryder using the get-out clause is a very real option and would be supported by the Players association.

Damo also told us Hird wouldn't survive the weekend.

Best communications specialist in the business.

 

[tim cotrill]

apparentlyy essendon have demanded Hartlett (our highest draft pick) hahaha **** I can't deal with this club anymore.