Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,254
- 71,636
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #1,459
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
If Parker is so good why aren’t Sydney giving him what he’s apparently worth
well he’s isn’t playing footy for us now is he?
Instant upgradeYou're gonna lose Cerra, Neale is an instant upgrade, takes attention off Serong and Brayshaw as they continue to develop and gives you the luxury of playing Fyfe up forward more often. Neale and a preserved Fyfe will put you in finals along with the natural development of your list. If Dockers want that they'll have to give up something of value for it.
Something else that people forget is that it wasn't just any pick 6 that went to Fremantle for Neale, it was in the 2018 draft, which was the most hyped in years. Draft watchers said that there were 8 prospects there who were truly elite and would be #1 pick contenders in most other years (PMBangers correct me if I'm wrong). So it was a particularly valuable pick 6, even if Fremantle went on to blow it.Sooo what's he worth realistically then mate? At aged 25 didn't he go for Pick 6 and 19 with 30 coming back to us? Surely he has gone down in value since then considering age? :S
Nealo going nowhere
yesInstant upgrade
Sure…except he’ll be pulling in the boots four years after he left and we’re paying for a footballer not a draft periodsIt will be exactly 3 trade periods apart. You do the math dude.
Almost identical age as Jeremy Cameron. We were told over and over 3 first round picks for an uncontracted free agent.
Sure…except he’ll be pulling in the boots four years after he left and we’re paying for a footballer not a draft periods
How would his old team mates at Freo feel ?.
Most likely outcomeHe signed a contract and should be made to honour it.
I could see a 3 way trade between Freo, Brisbane and Carlton involving Neale and Cerra. I suspect supporters of all 3 teams wouldn't be happy with it which suggests it's probably on the money in terms of value. That said I don't see why Freo would be desperate to get Neale back given their list profile.
Carlton lose - Pick 6 + Future 2nd
Carlton Gain - Cerra + Pick 45 (Freo 3rd)
Brisbane Lose - Lachie Neale + Pick 18 (Brisbane 1st tied to Melbourne)
Brisbane Gain - Pick 6 (Carlton 1st) + Carlton Future 2nd
Fremantle Lose - Cerra + Pick 45
Fremantle Gain - Neale + Pick 18
I could see a 3 way trade between Freo, Brisbane and Carlton involving Neale and Cerra. I suspect supporters of all 3 teams wouldn't be happy with it which suggests it's probably on the money in terms of value. That said I don't see why Freo would be desperate to get Neale back given their list profile.
Carlton lose - Pick 6 + Future 2nd
Carlton Gain - Cerra + Pick 45 (Freo 3rd)
Brisbane Lose - Lachie Neale + Pick 18 (Brisbane 1st tied to Melbourne)
Brisbane Gain - Pick 6 (Carlton 1st) + Carlton Future 2nd
Fremantle Lose - Cerra + Pick 45
Fremantle Gain - Neale + Pick 18
Bookmark this and revisit in 2 years
This trade scenario could workI could see a 3 way trade between Freo, Brisbane and Carlton involving Neale and Cerra. I suspect supporters of all 3 teams wouldn't be happy with it which suggests it's probably on the money in terms of value. That said I don't see why Freo would be desperate to get Neale back given their list profile.
Carlton lose - Pick 6 + Future 2nd
Carlton Gain - Cerra + Pick 45 (Freo 3rd)
Brisbane Lose - Lachie Neale + Pick 18 (Brisbane 1st tied to Melbourne)
Brisbane Gain - Pick 6 (Carlton 1st) + Carlton Future 2nd
Fremantle Lose - Cerra + Pick 45
Fremantle Gain - Neale + Pick 18
That is pure dog s**tI could see a 3 way trade between Freo, Brisbane and Carlton involving Neale and Cerra. I suspect supporters of all 3 teams wouldn't be happy with it which suggests it's probably on the money in terms of value. That said I don't see why Freo would be desperate to get Neale back given their list profile.
Carlton lose - Pick 6 + Future 2nd
Carlton Gain - Cerra + Pick 45 (Freo 3rd)
Brisbane Lose - Lachie Neale + Pick 18 (Brisbane 1st tied to Melbourne)
Brisbane Gain - Pick 6 (Carlton 1st) + Carlton Future 2nd
Fremantle Lose - Cerra + Pick 45
Fremantle Gain - Neale + Pick 18
Brisbane fans will hate it going off this thread but I think that's the best I can hope forI could see a 3 way trade between Freo, Brisbane and Carlton involving Neale and Cerra. I suspect supporters of all 3 teams wouldn't be happy with it which suggests it's probably on the money in terms of value. That said I don't see why Freo would be desperate to get Neale back given their list profile.
Carlton lose - Pick 6 + Future 2nd
Carlton Gain - Cerra + Pick 45 (Freo 3rd)
Brisbane Lose - Lachie Neale + Pick 18 (Brisbane 1st tied to Melbourne)
Brisbane Gain - Pick 6 (Carlton 1st) + Carlton Future 2nd
Fremantle Lose - Cerra + Pick 45
Fremantle Gain - Neale + Pick 18
Bookmark this and revisit in 2 years
Neale moved to Brissie, and made his bed with a contract that goes to the end of next year.
He now wants to return because his partner wants to be around family in WA.
Flip flopping is not a good look. You can’t keep changing your mind on a whim. How would his old team mates at Freo feel ?.
A contract is a contract, hold out till the end of the contract.
Brisbane fans will hate it going off this thread but I think that's the best I can hope for
He signed a contract and should be made to honour it.
Brisbane fans will hate it going off this thread but I think that's the best I can hope for
You expect Cerra to outperform Lachie Neale over the next two years?