Preview Changes/Squad/Team Discussion vs Hawks thread

[Flawed Genius]

Go nuts everybody.

MacMillan needs a rest. Garlett out.

Thomas back in. Mullett, maybe?

 

[h3LLo chitty]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

firrito cannot defend

 

[Mixed Results]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

OUT: C. Delaney, Garlett, Edwards
In: Thomas, Anthony, McMahon

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

What there anything in Ziebell getting subbed off early?
Thanks

 

[Flawed Genius]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

What there anything in Ziebell getting subbed off early?
Thanks

Precautionary, sore back.

Should play next week.

 

[year of the roo]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

OUT: C. Delaney, Garlett, Edwards
In: Thomas, Anthony, McMahon

I like Cam Delaney, I really do. I just don't like our tall, slow backline. Dropping him for McMahon just makes it slower, although we do need Loose back desperately. Bit of a dilemma there.

Garlett played today like someone who hasn't played AFL for a very long time. I'd like to see him get another chance, but it must be noted that he was terrible. Bombed away blindly, used it poorly, but at least got his hands on it. Bringing in LA for him though changes nothing, cannot agree with that.

Edwards took some good marks and presented well. Just used it poorly. No VFL game this week means no one pressuring for his spot. He stays.

I wonder how fit Ziebell and Jmac are? Looked lethargic all game. One more week until the bye though, perhaps Jmac as the sub next week to get him through.

 

[Psicosis]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

OUT: C. Delaney, Garlett, Edwards
In: Thomas, Anthony, McMahon

Cameron Delaney? Um No.

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Precautionary, sore back.

Should play next week.

Ok cheers

 

[Black Diamond]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Edwards was fair.

MacMillan is the only out I'd consider. HMac stays out even if fit, Black stays in, Wright stays forward.

 

[jasps1]

C delaney should not go out... His ability to read the play and his disposal along with his dash is what we need.

Not sure what reasons you'd be dropping him....

 

[Moti]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Fan of Jamie, but looks shot. In Mullett.

Garlett out for Thomas.

Mc Mahon though the VFL if possible considering the lay off and Monster a big no no

 

[AGC]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Give Cruize a decent run in the side. Not enough to give someone 50 minutes to get up to speed then drop them

 

[year of the roo]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Give Cruize a decent run in the side. Not enough to give someone 50 minutes to get up to speed then drop them

Agreed, when was his last senior game? 10 months ago?

 

[THE MOEMAN]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

OUT: Garlett, Macmillan
IN: Thomas, McKenzie/Mullett

 

[Fart Cummings]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

no mention of cunnington being dropped? or is it just a given he plays every week because he might be lenny hayes in the future!

sorry does someone have a stat to pull out that he tagged someone/played 58% game time/did an awesome sheppard on the half back flank!

 

[Psychic Roo]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

firrito cannot defend

at the end, he zoned off and was burned by a pass into the middle. did the same last week and arguably cost the last goal as paul roos pointed out - that needs to be dealt with..

 

[winalotroos]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

firrito cannot defend

Are you kidding ?

Spud was good running the ball out of the back line

 

[winalotroos]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

OUT: Garlett, Macmillan
IN: Thomas, McKenzie/Mullett

Agree Mc millian is in need of a rest. LT back in.

Not sure about Garlett, he did Burn the ball at times in the last qtr, is Mullett the right one to come in?

 

[Kimbo]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

C delaney should not go out... His ability to read the play and his disposal along with his dash is what we need.

Not sure what reasons you'd be dropping him....

And he's beginning to adjust to the pace of the game. Already.

Some very good signs from a young tall. He does a few heart in mouth things, like Scotty T, but so far, so good.

Is Loose ready, and given his lay off, is he likely to come straight back in?

 

[Flawed Genius]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

MacMillan out for MacMahon, Garlett out for Thomas?

 

[Bigeasy]

Are you kidding ?

Spud was good running the ball out of the back line

No he isn't and I agree with him. Apart from running the ball out of defence which invariably results in a turnover, he can't win his fair share of one on ones, can't tackle and is sub par in body on body work. I love Spud but he is a liability now.

 

[naturally north]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Out: Edwards

In: Thomas

 

[muttley45]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

in: please,a bit of intensity and urgency,correction,make that a LOT of both,

out:corralling and flapping arms around instead of laying hurtful tackles resulting in turnovers,and quote "walking the ball out of defense"

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

No he isn't and I agree with him. Apart from running the ball out of defence which invariably results in a turnover, he can't win his fair share of one on ones, can't tackle and is sub par in body on body work. I love Spud but he is a liability now.

His poor decision making is costing the team goals.

That effort when he tried to kick the ball and had an airy was a joke.

 

[Joshen]

Re: Changes/Squad/Team vs Hawks

Out: MacMillan (needs a rest), still want think we are too tall down back but apart from a few brain fades (as per normal) everyone was generally good (especially the Delaneys)
In: Thomas, Mullet would be next

If McMahon is ready I want him to build fitness in the VFL first