Autopsy Famous against the odds win against North Melbourne.

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Coaches awards
VOTES PLAYER (CLUB)
10
Justin McInerney (SYD)
8 Jack Ziebell (NMFC)
5 Jy Simpkin (NMFC)
3 Callum Mills (SYD)
3 Oliver Florent (SYD)
1 Jake Lloyd (SYD)

AFLCA Champion Player of the Year - AFL Coaches Association Awards - AFL Coaches Association
Justin, Tom, Chad, Errol, Nick - so 5 players 22 years or under, of the 11 Swans with votes
#​
1
2
3
4
Total
5​
Isaac Heeney​
5​
10​
15​
14​
Callum Mills​
8​
3​
11​
26​
Luke Parker​
10​
10​
27​
Justin Mcinerney​
10​
10​
13​
Oliver Florent​
5​
3​
8​
30​
Tom McCartin​
2​
2​
39​
Patrick McCartin​
2​
2​
1​
Chad Warner​
1​
1​
21​
Errol Gulden​
1​
1​
22​
Nick Blakey​
1​
1​
44​
Jake Lloyd​
1​
1​

No Heeney? Coaches must've been on the glass didgeridoo
 
It's up...

Clearly I’m not smart enough to interpret these obscure thread titles.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I was thinking maybe they were trying to reward a 4 quarter performance, but then they have McInerney up there.
The rest were more consistent along the game.

Without Heeney we probably lose that game by about 5 goals. Absolutely ridiculous.
 
Well it makes sense if you are a fan of the slow steady build up why you’d be an advocate for him.
I’m seeing faster transition across the league which is why I used the word obsolete when describing him.
I’m not saying he can’t evolve into something else but IMO what he brings right now isn’t cutting the mustard.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

You make a good point..but there’s always room for ‘tempo’.

To me Harry is more of a worry...he’s had poor match ups..but he seems to be being easily exposed....
 
AFL Coaches awards
VOTES PLAYER (CLUB)
10
Justin McInerney (SYD)
8 Jack Ziebell (NMFC)
5 Jy Simpkin (NMFC)
3 Callum Mills (SYD)
3 Oliver Florent (SYD)
1 Jake Lloyd (SYD)

AFLCA Champion Player of the Year - AFL Coaches Association Awards - AFL Coaches Association
Justin, Tom, Chad, Errol, Nick - so 5 players 22 years or under, of the 11 Swans with votes
#​
1
2
3
4
Total
5​
Isaac Heeney​
5​
10​
15​
14​
Callum Mills​
8​
3​
11​
26​
Luke Parker​
10​
10​
27​
Justin Mcinerney​
10​
10​
13​
Oliver Florent​
5​
3​
8​
30​
Tom McCartin​
2​
2​
39​
Patrick McCartin​
2​
2​
1​
Chad Warner​
1​
1​
21​
Errol Gulden​
1​
1​
22​
Nick Blakey​
1​
1​
44​
Jake Lloyd​
1​
1​

Jake Lloyd the teacher's pet.. this is why our club is just good and nothing else. His mistakes get glossed over somehow and gets votes for little impact.

24 possessions
Just 5 contested
DE 67% - 8 missess
3 tackles
11 Pressure Acts - 12th in Swans
359m 9th - with all that ball.
2 Score involvements

How would you like to kick for us
BLAKEY, 4th year, just found his position and really travelling now
MCINERNEY, 3rd year, run, cover and kicking above average
CAMPBELL, 2nd year, playing out of position
LLOYD - 10th year, What did he do to get a vote? 4th best for us, your kidding us.

If LONGMIRE then normal pet, if NOBLE then put it in due to Blakey advising.



Sent from my SM-G990E using Tapatalk
 
Lloyd wa
Lloyd was poor this week but played well vs Geelong and the Dogs, some of the hate he gets on here is over the top though.

The younger guys consistently commit far worse turnovers out of defence than Lloyd does (which is fine, it happens sometimes) and no one
As I unde
Jake Lloyd the teacher's pet.. this is why our club is just good and nothing else. His mistakes get glossed over somehow and gets votes for little impact.

24 possessions
Just 5 contested
DE 67% - 8 missess
3 tackles
11 Pressure Acts - 12th in Swans
359m 9th - with all that ball.
2 Score involvements

How would you like to kick for us
BLAKEY, 4th year, just found his position and really travelling now
MCINERNEY, 3rd year, run, cover and kicking above average
CAMPBELL, 2nd year, playing out of position
LLOYD - 10th year, What did he do to get a vote? 4th best for us, your kidding us.

If LONGMIRE then normal pet, if NOBLE then put it in due to Blakey advising.



Sent from my SM-G990E using Tapatalk
rsta it, kick ins are a disposal. If so, then Lloyd was avg at best. Someone said he played well against Gellong - I had my eye on him all game and he was god awful. Really rusty. I am still backing him to improve week on week though.
 
Overall I do fi
You make a good point..but there’s always room for ‘tempo’.

To me Harry is more of a worry...he’s had poor match ups..but he seems to be being easily exposed....
Cunningham has been a worry this season, seems to have dropped right off and I can't figure out why.
 
Overall I do fi

Cunningham has been a worry this season, seems to have dropped right off and I can't figure out why.
Not going to be any easier this week with Ryan, Rioli and Jones loitering around. If we don't dominate the contest and let weagles get multiple inside 50s, WC may catch us with our pants down.
 
Harry needs some help. Even Nick Smith had Mattner, Mills, Laidler to share the load for much of his career. Would rate Shaw, Malceski as better defenders than Lloyd, JMac etc.

Looking forward to having COR, or Fox back there, allows Campbell, JMac, Blakey, Lloyd to rotate the HB roles, with JMac and a released Campbell the outside mid role that JMac dominated 2nd half vs the Roos.
 
I watched this game for some reason

I did the thing

What a disgusting game

Swans
Mills 9
-
Heeney 7
Warner 6
Rowbottom 6
McInerney 6
-
Florent 5
Reid 5
Campbell 5
T McCartin 4
Kennedy 4
Rampe 4
Ladhams 4
Franklin 4
-
Bell 3
Lloyd 3
P McCartin 3
Ronke (s) 3
McLean 3
Cunningham 3
Gulden 2
Blakey 2
Parker 2
Hayward 2



Kangaroos
Goldstein 8
-
Ziebell 7
Stephenson 6
McKay 6
McDonald 6
Walker 6
-
Simpkin 5
Scott 5
Davies-Uniacke 4
Corr 4
Horne-Francis 4
Mahony 4
Young 4
-
Hall 3
Xerri 3
Taylor 3
Zurhaar 2
Turner 2
Greenwood 2
Perez 2
Bosenavulagi 2
-
Larkey 1
Bonar (s) 0
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top