Who is the best Key Forward of the 21st Century?

[PhatBoy]

WTF? I cant believe I didnt know that. Also makes no sense.

I edited my post for accuracy. It was actually the year after his 100 goal season but yes he won the Coleman medal in 2005 as well and was left out.

 

[PhatBoy]

It happened to Scott Cummings as well.

 

[GoldbergsGold]

I would say Fevola is the example of a flash in the pan type player, who probably could've been the best of the lot but because he was a dumb man-child with a penchant for gambling and alcohol we'll never find out.

Tredrea is absolutely incomparable to a Fevola, Tex etc.

Tredrea is for sure in that middle ground with Riewoldt and Brown for mine. Pavlich probably a step ahead of those three only because of his ability to play everywhere, and had he played strictly KPF for his entire career he'd likely have gone close to Lance.

I get your frustration and really would not be concerned with anyone empty enough to suggest Travis Cloke is in the same league as Fevola, let alone Tredrea lol

Fevola was one of the greatest wasted talents ever. If he had been more serious, he could have been even better than Franklin, Carey and Ablett Sr. He pulled off some incredible skills, loads of goals and he wasn't a very serious footballer. Also, had he played in a more successful team, that could have help him be much better than he was.