Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[gillo94]

I don't want one of Yarran or Henderson, just the pick in the late 20's or early 30's that you get for them.

Might want to check Carlisle's pre season, or the fact that he's spent much more time in the ruck than Henderson. Jake is a far superior prospect.

For a player that wants out id be taking anything that is remotely decent than pushing your luck with something that won't happen

Jake is a very good player and will play a big role but your making it out like his Buddy Franklin

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Maybe true but, I was only asking about Hendo??

This thread really isn't about Hendo though. I'm pointing out that they both have had similar years. Nothing too special. Yes Carlisle has spent some time in the ruck. He is averaging a dismal 3.5 hit outs a match and from being around the ball that much, I would expect him to be averaging more than just the 11 disposals a game.

I am sure it will work it self out. I just think you guys will get ripped if he leaves. Whether it be to Carlton or any other club.

 

[gillo94]

Second rounder won't be taken to well by EFC. This draft falls away heavily around that pick...

If the draft is weak would Bombers go for young mature age key position player?

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

If the draft is weak would Bombers go for young mature age key position player?

Well yes, considering our KPP stocks will be in a bad bad place if Carlisle leaves.

 

[HULK HOGAN]

This thread really isn't about Hendo though. I'm pointing out that they both have had similar years. Nothing too special. Yes Carlisle has spent some time in the ruck. He is averaging a dismal 3.5 hit outs a match and from being around the ball that much, I would expect him to be averaging more than just the 11 disposals a game.

I am sure it will work it self out. I just think you guys will get ripped if he leaves. Whether it be to Carlton or any other club.

A simple yes or no answer to my question would've been fine, it wasn't a hard question......

 

[HereComesJuddy]

A simple yes or no answer to my question would've been fine, it wasn't a hard question......

You may need to re read. What I just replied to wasn't a yes, no question... oh Hulk

 

[HULK HOGAN]

You may need to re read. What I just replied to wasn't a yes, no question... oh Hulk

Oh Juddy....... The simple question was HAS HENDOS FORM AFFECTED HIS TRADE VALUE??? How hard is that to answer?

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Oh Juddy....... The simple question was HAS HENDOS FORM AFFECTED HIS TRADE VALUE??? How hard is that to answer?

No

 

[blueiris]

Oh Juddy....... The simple question was HAS HENDOS FORM AFFECTED HIS TRADE VALUE??? How hard is that to answer?

You could seriously say the same for Carlisle's form

 

[MightyDons4]

You could seriously say the same for Carlisle's form

Come off the back of no pre season and has been forced to play out of position. He's basically a second year KPF so what do you expect?

 

[blueiris]

Come off the back of no pre season and has been forced to play out of position. He's basically a second year KPF so what do you expect?

To be fair Henderson is also being played out of position he's really a defender but Mick chose to play him forward

 

[HULK HOGAN]

You could seriously say the same for Carlisle's form

Could you?? I couldn't give a shite!! I was just asking about Hendersons trade value???????????????????

 

[MightyDons4]

To be fair Henderson is also being played out of position he's really a defender but Mick choose to play him forward

Fair enough, but I was talking about Carlisle. Pre seasons have a massive impact on a players form throughout the season. Nic Nat completed his first full pre season and I'd say he's now the best ruckman in the competition.

 

[lachie charm]

To be fair Henderson is also being played out of position he's really a defender but Mick chose to play him forward

Shhh you can't fight stupid with sense.

 

[rusman]

If he leaves, 2 picks in the 20-30 range from which ever club would be around the best EFC could hope for.

I'd be disappointed with him leaving as I doubt we would get anything close to his value with these picks but it is a buyers market.

 

[blueiris]

If he leaves, 2 picks in the 20-30 range from which ever club would be around the best EFC could hope for.

I'd be disappointed with him leaving as I doubt we would get anything close to his value with these picks but it is a buyers market.

That probably wouldn't be out of the question with Future picks able to be traded you would just hope a team that needs a defender will target him

 

[MaddAdam]

Is he also leaving because his partner told him to?

 

[Conor Mckenna]

If the situation was reversed, could you really see Essendon swapping picks with Carlton? Doubt it. Dodoro definitely wouldn't and I think we all know that

I can see it happening,

There'd be a quick meeting,

"who you picking if we swap" says Dodoro, "Laverde or Goddard, we all know you need a tall.."

Were taking Boekhurst says the Carton brains, but don't tell anyone, we'd hate for him to get pinched from right under our nose..

OK says dodoro, we'll swap and settle for Laverde and whatever else you can spare...

Just because you gave us a massive gift last year don't expect anything in return...Overlooking Laverde will prove to be a huge error...

 

[Conor Mckenna]

Is he also leaving because his partner told him to?

Is that you mrs Stevens?

 

[HBF]

You would think their first pick will be on the table, and then haggling over what else.

Would that be enough? Unlikely to be a top 10 selection.

 

[Thunder_Dan]

If Carlton were to pick him up would they play him forward or back? They really need both haha

 

[eth-dog]

A Scientific Study found:

Average % rate of delusional fans at 17 AFL Clubs = 40%

Average % rate of delusional fans at Carlton FC = 95%

Fixed

 

[carnthedons]

If Carlton were to pick him up would they play him forward or back? They really need both haha

I'll forget the second bit but Jake's a better KPF than anything they've got and KPD than anything they've got. To my mind defence is the bigger need immediately so if I were them it'd be CHB for sure.

 

[Ants]

Would that be enough? Unlikely to be a top 10 selection.

No, which is why I said "and then haggling over what else". That's where the debate would be. I would think we would want more than their 2nd round pick, they would try and get away with as little as possible.

 

[ferrisb]

Sorry if already covered, but what do you think is a fair salary for Carlisle? Take WADA out of the equation.

I've only seen Carlisle discussed in terms of picks, but it would also take a decent chunk of cap to pick him up. Both need to be considered.