Autopsy AFL 2023 Round 22 - Pies v Cats Fri August 11th 7:50pm EST (MCG)

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

The kind of detail a Carlton supporter wouldn’t go to if it was any other team on the receiving end

Don't flatter yourself.
I couldn't care about the teams. I look at this stuff all the time regardless of who's playing. It also benefits my team more for the Pies to win.

Although I noticed that instead of disputing the argument, you're just trying to downplay and discredit the source.

 

[Toffee Lion]

Ask chef about the Dogs in Geelong.
More chance of Everton beating Liverpool at Anfield.

Only been 2 years mate and I'm still celebrating it.

 

[PizzaPie]

I'll make it easy for you, De Goey has easily outperformed Elliott in the finals. In fact, he and Pendlebury elevate their usual output once the real stuff begins.
You can essentially chalk in De Goey for 25 disposals and a goal in every final coming up.

Asking one question and then seemingly answering it for someone using a completely different question doesn't make anything easier haha. I'm very confident JDG has indeed outperformed Elliott in finals and that it could be easily demonstrated. If that's the official definition of More Clutch, you can count on my vote for JDG. It seems though that it would be simpler to say JDG has a better finals performance record than Elliott, no? Saves trying to shoehorn one made-up title into another made-up title more weighted toward recency and end-of-game match-winning goals.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Is that you Donald Trump?

Don't you dare compare me to that piece of human trash.
Discuss the validity of the pic/umpire's call as much as you like. The childish insults say more about you than me.

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

Clearly angles are something you are not familiar with.

But let's humour you and say your correct, he still juggled the ball over the line anyway and it should have been a throw in.

Just completely inept from all the umps tonight.

Feel free to educate me (all of us). I'm more than happy to admit mistakes or improve my knowledge when something of substance is offered. So...

 

[PenAndPaper]

Chris Scott

Chris Scott

Age

47

Ht

182cm

Wt

89kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.6

4star

K

11.2

4star

HB

5.4

4star

M

5.1

5star

T

1.6

4star

G

0.4

3star

No current season stats available

D

13.2

4star

K

10.2

4star

HB

3.0

3star

M

2.2

3star

T

2.8

5star

G

0.4

3star

has the nerve to complain about the bounce but is fine with the two jezza goals lmao

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

Asking one question and then seemingly answering it for someone using a completely different question doesn't make anything easier haha. I'm very confident JDG has indeed outperformed Elliott in finals and that it could be easily demonstrated. If that's the official definition of More Clutch, you can count on my vote for JDG. It seems though that it would be simpler to say JDG has a better finals performance record than Elliott, no? Saves trying to shoehorn one made-up title into another made-up title more weighted toward recency and end-of-game match-winning goals.

Don't even know why you're bothering with this guy. He's an idiot.

 

[My Tilly]

Don't even know why you're bothering with this guy. He's an idiot.

Says the bloke who quotes a twitter post about some girl in a crowd who supposedly looks like Donald Trump

I now you love your little Jamie, but hey' learn to accept criticism like most middle aged men can.

 

[adammania9]

Anyway, another round of applause to these two teams who either play the best games of the season, or the worst. Besides the clashes against the historic other big four clubs, the lead-up to and including games against Geelong is always a pleasure to experience as a Pies member.

 

[PieLebo87]

You sure Hawkins was out? Pretty sure only Collingwood had injuries

Ours is the current Brownlow medal favourite and the most likely AA captain. Does it bother you when the media talk about that?

 

[Mr Meow]

Ours is the current Brownlow medal favourite and the most likely AA captain. Does it bother you when the media talk about that?

Honestly who cares. Both sides had important injuries, the better side won, it was a decent and fairly competitive game.

 

[PieLebo87]

Honestly who cares. Both sides had important injuries, the better side won, it was a decent and fairly competitive game.

Agreed.

I’m just responding to those having a whinge about commentators commenting on injuries. Woop di doo, they spoke about Collingwood’s injuries yet people do the whole ‘what about my team what about my team’ nonsense.

 

[PieLebo87]

Worst call of the night was not to recall that bounce to start the third quarter. May as well have lined McStsy up from 20 before the siren.

I always wait for the week you barrack for us against a team you despise more, but that week never comes.

 

[PieLebo87]

Worst as it was so obvious there was no excuse not blindsided no doubt.

Would love to hear your theory around whether Cameron’s last goal of the third and first of the last quarter were actually goals or OOB.

 

[Spook]

Well that’s pretty much how our season should finish up to be honest. If we win next two and make it, I‘ll hope but know it’ll be false deep down. Need to take stock, take the lessons learnt and try and contend again.

You can win your next 2 and still finish 10th. I agree, that would be a fair reflection Of your season.

 

[Spook]

He signalled a behind then called it a goal.

The ump tapping their chest is not signalling a behind; it is signalling “Mine”. As in I had a clear site and I could make the decision to the boundary umps. It usually is done for a behind because it signals for the boundaries that they don’t need to get the ball and return it to the centre. In this case, Rodan signals to the boundaries ump that they don’t need to return the ball to the centre, not because it was a behind but because being game over the boundary umps don’t need to return a ball to the centre. He was being a technical smarty pants.

https://usafl.com/files/umpiring/Goal_Umpiring.pdf

 

[chef]

Ask chef about the Dogs in Geelong.
More chance of Everton beating Liverpool at Anfield.

And im going again haha. Glutton for punishment.

 

[Bunnings]

When’s the last time BOTH teams in the GF didn’t make Finals the following year? Id say never?

1963 someone said on radio

 

[ChristianBoy]

Would love to hear your theory around whether Cameron’s last goal of the third and first of the last quarter were actually goals or OOB.

First one looked out but so did Tom Mitchell’s mark a few minutes earlier by the same boundary.

Second one was I thought play on but I also thought Elliot had played on v Port Adelaide over the line.


The mark to Miochek was very bad as they umpire had a clear view.

They then didn’t pay Cameron’s which was clearly a mark.

Then not pay Rattas and pin him for holding the ball.

 

[Fadge]

I think they're tracking along fine.

Holmes is only about to reach 50 games next week. How many footballers are stars in their first 50 games?
De Koning 40 games, Bruhn 48 games, Stengle 58 games, Henry 45 games. These guys already look like they belong so imagine pumping another 40 games into them.

It was the midfield they were discussing.

I guess it's time the wheel turned for Geelong... you've had two decades of all-time greats going through your midfield, time for a few years of being a middling club (I hope).

 

[Nicho50]

This guys lost it danger had 10 clearances the most 11 inside 50s the most and 3rd for meters gained he was a bull!

I said finish up before going on a season to many like plenty of others have done.

 

[10571z]

No, it wasn’t a dream. Last night we saw the worst umpiring decision in the history of the AFL/VFL.

 

[Stumpy Pete]

They asked him if the Cameron one was out of bounds

"I didnt see it hand on heart , but those that know a lot about the game said it wasnt out " LO

First one looked out but so did Tom Mitchell’s mark a few minutes earlier by the same boundary.

Second one was I thought play on but I also thought Elliot had played on v Port Adelaide over the line.


The mark to Miochek was very bad as they umpire had a clear view.

They then didn’t pay Cameron’s which was clearly a mark.

Then not pay Rattas and pin him for holding the ball.

On the second Cameron one no one is questioning Close playing on - people are questioning how Cameron can receive a handball while both he and then ball are out of bounds. This is an unquestionably incorrect call.

See the picture below your post for clear evidence.

Regards

S. Pete

 

[Osho]

Impressive Pies. Fantastic.

Those chasing teams, need to keep plotting. There's still a gap.

Qtr2 pressure, phenomenal from Collingwood.

 

[Stumpy Pete]

View attachment 1771536
No, it wasn’t a dream. Last night we saw the worst umpiring decision in the history of the AFL/VFL.

While this non-decision is very, very bad - it isn’t quite as bad as the non-decision involving Sydney and Essendon and Rampe shaking the post. That non-decision cost a team (Essendon) the game and affected the order of the final eight.

Regards

S. Pete