Which obscure player would you trade for Pick 1?

[Topkent]

Dylan Grimes. I reckon he is every bit as important as Rance without the personality or good looks.

 

[74561347]

stefan carey.

for obvious reasons

 

[ioppolo]

De Goey. He'd replace Lecras in 2019 with the veteran's retirement.

Cripps - Darling - De Goey
Rioli - Kennedy - Ryan

Boner worthy

 

[Spacedog]

Tim Taranto

 

[Spacedog]

Dylan Grimes. I reckon he is every bit as important as Rance without the personality or good looks.

People are overrating Grimes and underrating Rance lately. Rance is a lot better and more important than grimes and always will be, Grimes would probably admit this himself.

 

[Sellout Scully]

Fogarty from the Crows. Will be a gun.

 

[Topkent]

People are overrating Grimes and underrating Rance lately. Rance is a lot better and more important than grimes and always will be, Grimes would probably admit this himself.

Meh. Grimes and Astbury allow Rance to have the impact he does. Besides it's my hypothetical pick to trade so buzz off

 

[Roobs321]

Toby Greene

Haha, could totally see that. The talented, somewhat polarizing, small-medium sized forward moving to Richmond, has precedence.

 

[Thegibbsgamble]

Fogarty from the Crows. Will be a gun.

Local boy

We would need to be sure we're getting something better

Although milera is worth pick one

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

Aaron Naughton

His debut season has been unprecedented.

And I stand by that claim

 

[Baird]

And I stand by that claim

He's only nineteen! (19)

 

[10571z]

Is there anything more overated than the number 1 pick?

Honestly “Clayton Oliver” is not obscure. If you got someone close like that as a number one you’d be stoked. Very very rarely number one is the best

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

He's only nineteen! (19)

Was deserving of the Rising Star last year, alongside Witherden.

 

[Aussie_boy]

Is there anything more overated than the number 1 pick?

Honestly “Clayton Oliver” is not obscure. If you got someone close like that as a number one you’d be stoked. Very very rarely number one is the best

Generally do agree but think Sam Walsh will be a bit of an outlier, already looks at home. Seems to be if you draft a KPP with it you're just asking for trouble.

 

[Baird]

Was deserving of the Rising Star last year, alongside Witherden.

Nah no way

 

[Cursed Cat]

Fact is there is barely such thing as an obscure player in these days of footy oversaturation - I reckon the closest thing we've seen to something like this in the past few years though was the Suns parting with #2 for Freo's Lachie Weller.

 

[The King!]

Anthony Davis

 

[Chaisa]

Generally do agree but think Sam Walsh will be a bit of an outlier, already looks at home. Seems to be if you draft a KPP with it you're just asking for trouble.

Though I think that might be the exception to the rule.

 

[PAFC_1870]

De Goey

Yeah he's the guy

Not worth it typically but I'd do it.

In an average draft mind you...

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Toby McLean, pretty close to elite at such a young age. Doesn’t get the credit of a Bomtempelli but more consistent and damaging.

Aiden Bonar. Loved what he showed this year. Taken at 13 last year and surprised with how early he started to impact games. The next Charlie Curnow.

You obviously don't actually know your football, although Toby is good and will get even better, ball in hand i don't think there is a more precise kick and damaging player then Bont

 

[Topkent]

Generally do agree but think Sam Walsh will be a bit of an outlier, already looks at home. Seems to be if you draft a KPP with it you're just asking for trouble.

Yeah thats what they said about Scully, Murphy, Gibbs, Watts, Whitfield, Petracca, Weiterman etc
You never get so see their weakness as a junior, Walshs will be found soon enough and then the real test comes

 

[Quinz]

Yeah thats what they said about Scully, Murphy, Gibbs, Watts, Whitfield, Petracca, Weiterman etc
You never get so see their weakness as a junior, Walshs will be found soon enough and then the real test comes

It’s a rare number one draft pick who doesn’t get touted as the “most AFL ready junior we’ve seen in years”.

 

[Boxhead_31]

Mitch McGovern

You could be giving Carlton Mitch and pick 1 now that’s a deal

 

[TJASTA]

Jack Graham