Preview Changes & Pre-match Discussion vs. Melbourne Demons (Round 12, Mon 10/06 3:20pm MCG) FREEZE MND

[JC83]

Mate he hasn’t put a foot wrong since he came back. He would have been dropped otherwise. Beams who has not contributed all year would go before him.

No player gets dropped on a 2 goal game. None. Get real.

Bryce Gibbs ?

 

[KillerMagpies]

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on. Changes for next week. In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Have to agree. He takes that shot in the last from inside 50 and kicks it we win. How he could instead handball to someone 60 out who isn't a goalkicker and has pressure is ridiculous.

 

[MyManLynch]

Is Beams carrying an injury? Seemed not to push himself to contests today.
We can’t take a contested mark inside 50 (big forwards)...only JDG can pluck the odd one.
Need Cox back next week.
Many passengers today.
Poor skills, poor decisions, poor game, poor result.
Wait for VFL tomorrow...hopefully Sier, Daics, IQ & Scharenberg have good games.
Sier, Daicos & IQ must be getting close to selection.
A few senior players need a kick in the pants...
A good team would have buried us today.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Out - Beams, Aish
In - Sier, Quaynor

 

[Leviathan Pie]

You still think Melbourne will carve us up in the midfield?

Our midfield ******* sucks bro.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

We need Creative. - Sier
And Dare - Quaynor
And Grunt -Sier, Adams

But neither are knocking down the door or injured.

I'd just play them (the uninjured) anyway.

You think Sier is creative....

 

[The Plowking]

You dont think Sier is creative....?
^efa

 

[Leviathan Pie]

What should happen:

In: Adams, Cox, Daicos, Quaynor, Sier
Out: Phillips, Reid, Thomas, Hoskin-Elliott, Brown

What will happen:

In: Crocker
Out: Aish/Varcoe

Lack of D.Beams in your outs is ridiculous.

 

[Thatsmyname]

Well when you put it like that he's a ****en one man clearance machine, look at him shovel it out

 

[JM#1]

No Ins or Outs will fix the current problems. However, it's time for Thomas to be dropped surely.

 

[Kappa]

Thomas and varcoe will be nervous, both on the chopping block and neither is young

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Phillips has good endurance, but his kicking is a liability at the moment. One instance was when he had three teammates to pick from just near the centre of the ground, and his pass didnt hit any of them. Freo won possession, and got a goal from the turnover. If we are serious, we would be sending him to the VFL to work on his disposal.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

No Ins or Outs will fix the current problems. However, it's time for Thomas to be dropped surely.

And Beams, unfortunately

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

I wonder what Adelaide would want for a Jenkins/Gibbs packaged trade. Jenkins as a forward/relief ruck, and Gibbs has his critics, but is a excellent user of the ball.

 

[AmericanMustard]

I wonder what Adelaide would want for a Jenkins/Gibbs packaged trade. Jenkins as a forward/relief ruck, and Gibbs has his critics, but is a excellent user of the ball.

They’d pay us to take both of them.

 

[Kappa]

I wonder what Adelaide would want for a Jenkins/Gibbs packaged trade. Jenkins as a forward/relief ruck, and Gibbs has his critics, but is a excellent user of the ball.

If we pay their salaries they'll give us a 3rd rounder to take em...

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

We seriously need to hurry up and move on from Tom Phillips. He may not have had as many turnovers as usual this week but it's honestly like having the Lonie brothers without the footskills running along the wing. Smashed all day by his direct opponents and continually rolling out piss weak efforts at winning contested balls. Bloke is a front runner of the highest echelon

I think in TAC cup footy, he had good running capacity and could get a heap of the footy, but his disposals were below average. Maybe we thought we could correct that part of his game in a professional environment, but it is clearly still a problem. Out of 10 passes, he will hit a target, conservatively 3 times. We have a talanted list, but we lack a couple more good users of the footy. Wells and Pendles are obviously the best, Moore not to bad, Sidey has his moments, maybe Howe and
Quaynor looks a above average kick.
We need to bring in quality users of the footy, to complete the playing list.
Against the Saints, a player like Treloar went at 16% DE, and yesterday may have been worse.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

They’d pay us to take both of them.

I think we could use both of them quite nicely in our side.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Geelong and GWS had winnable games today and both had the positive mindset to gain the four points. WCE to do same tomorrow. Tigers beat Freo in WA with arguably their weakest line up for the year.Pies on home turf with a strengthened side with every thing to play for outplayed and outcoached by a more determined outfit who were not held back by inflated egos. Next week a must win which a premiership contender should capitalize on.
Changes for next week.
In- Daicos,Sier, Crocker
Out-Beams,Varcoe,Thomas



Still bemused by our lack of dominance for centre clearances given our strengths are meant to be our ruck and on ball division.

Crocker isn't going to win us games of footy. I would rather keep in Varcoe or Beams, if we were to go down that track. I actually like to see Quaynor debut on QB, if he has another strong VFL performance.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Lack of D.Beams in your outs is ridiculous.

I wanted to put Howe too. But we’ll save those 2 for after next week’s loss.

 

[surfer1]

Out: Aish , Thomas , Brown

In : Quaynor , Sier , Daicos

Really wish we had another forward in the 2s. Tall forward to replace Reid. He is so frustrating to watch.
Moves worse than cox


I actually thougjt he played ok

On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

If we pay their salaries they'll give us a 3rd rounder to take em...

Could be a better offer if a Phillips and Aish were thrown into the mix.

 

[Go Pies!!!!!]

Big game for some of the VFL boys today as a good performance could see a move to the seniors, to early to say who will come in but these players would be nervous.

Aish, Varcoe, Brown, Reid, Aish, Beams, Thomas, Phillips.

I want Cox straight in way to important to our structure.

What i would like to see

OUT: Reid, Aish, Thomas, Beams
IN: Cox, Quaynor, Daicos, Sier.

Time to send a message especially to Beams & Thomas.

On another note boy i had a mini heart attack when Grundy limped off

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

I wanted to put Howe too. But we’ll save those 2 for after next week’s loss.

I don't think we lose to Melbourne, particularly after yesterday's effort. If we do lose, then we have well and truly hit the wall...

 

[jmac70]

We need to add some creativity and grunt.

Out: Varcoe, Aish and Thomas
In: Daicos, IQ and Sier