Weitering
Recommitted Jonathon Marsh [requested trade to WA]
- Thread starter Mr Fonebone
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Shaneprice97
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 24, 2013
- 5,240
- 6,741
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Collingwood VFL
One of those cases where we wont get anything near his value to the club.
Few comments that we are losing Name Brown. Don't think we will now that we took Wells as a FA from North and that we're listing Frost and Marsh. He's a required player now and we'll offer him enough to keep him.
If we take his brother as a FA, would only help in keeping him.
If we take his brother as a FA, would only help in keeping him.
sr36
Hall of Famer
We won't get anything for Marsh, but I don't understand why Marchbank is going for a first rounder and Marsh is worth nothing. From what I've seen at senior level, I rate Marsh higher. I reckon he's going to be a bloody good player.
- Aug 20, 2010
- 14,582
- 19,325
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Do we have a pick in the 100's we could use on him?
- Aug 26, 2016
- 12,136
- 15,082
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
If he doesn't want to play anymore we're better off demoting him to the Rookie list and seeing where bis heads at next year.
Yep, what sucks is he's a much better player than Frost, and much younger, i'd pay pick 40 for him no worries if the rumours about a mental illness are false, we won't get that for him though
- Banned
- #134
Decent young backman. Worth putting a couple of years into. Disappointed he is leaving
sonnywalters
Cancelled
Oh yeah? - How many 20yo KPPs do you have on your list who are better? Name one.
sonnywalters
Cancelled
So Pearce - who is older than Marsh - is going improve a lot but Marsh wont improve at all?
OK right.....
sonnywalters
Cancelled
As you say - Collins and Allir are two years older.
Marchbank and Plowman are totally unproven. Plowman is 22 already.
Oscar McDonald has a LONG way to go...
Clutching at straws I think. See its not that easy is it.
Fact is Marsh is probably in the top 5 KDs in the country for his age.
Logan Austin shits on just about all the ones you listed (so thanks GWS
).Anyway, with Collingwood being on FTA a lot this year, I've seen Marsh play a bit. You would have to think a pick in the 35-50 region would be fair. Anything else would be overs or unders IMO.
His kicking is Port like sometimes though.
Real shame, he was coming along. However injury prone and his skills weren't elite but his desire is. He also has good run for a big man and runs through the lines. With the right players around him very handy player. Hope we get something for him, but more likely 60+. However he was a rookie as was Frost so getting any picks is a bonus.
Logan Austin shits on just about all the ones you listed (so thanks GWS
Anyway, with Collingwood being on FTA a lot this year, I've seen Marsh play a bit. You would have to think a pick in the 35-50 region would be fair. Anything else would be overs or unders IMO.
His kicking is Port like sometimes though.
The problem for collingwood is that with hamling and adams already looking to come to perth and west coast currently having the best key defender depth in the league he's the 3rd banana. I'm sure he could find a spot, particularly with brown almost certain to go east and collins and mckenzie maybe possibilities but i don't see how collingwood are going to get anymore than a third rounder for him.
Forgot to list him, problem is now for Marsh is that Adams and possibly Hamling are on the way back to WA and both play the same position and both sides would prefer either. And that West Coast are stocked with talls I just don't see why either side would pay what the pies would want for him.Logan Austin shits on just about all the ones you listed (so thanks GWS
Anyway, with Collingwood being on FTA a lot this year, I've seen Marsh play a bit. You would have to think a pick in the 35-50 region would be fair. Anything else would be overs or unders IMO.
His kicking is Port like sometimes though.
What do we want ? I hadn't heard.
Also, Adams manager said he's expressed an interest but not real concerned if he doesn't get there, or words to that effect. Footscary wont lose both Hamling and Adams. If Dogs re-sign Hamling, might be happy to trade Adams. If Hamling leaves, likely they retain the contracted Adams.
Why is it that every Collingwood play up for trade is rubbish? Oh I know....
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
dlanod
Moderator
- Sep 14, 2006
- 52,416
- 81,226
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- GWS; CCMariners; NQCowboys; Ravens
- Moderator
- #144
True for every one - a player wanting to join a club is rubbish and not worth anything, a player wanting to leave the club is worth everything ever. Once the player has joined the club, he's worth everything ever and vice versa.
Apex36
Hall of Famer
- Mar 26, 2014
- 39,081
- 81,612
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I'm just astounded that we had a non-Collingwood supporter go in to bat for Marshy in this thread. Common theme most of the time is Collingwood fans say what they think he's worth and everyone else screams at us about how we overrate our players.
Cheers sonnywalters
I wonder if he'd consider a move to Sydney where his brother lives? Couldn't guarantee him a game but wouldn't be a bad developing tall to have spare.
Hey I think you've got good players and stood up for Marsh too!
Yes, no problem. Maybe, just a small upgrade a late pick.
Last edited:
Similar threads
