Recommitted Elliott Himmelberg [OOC 2024] [Trade Requested to GWS - didn’t get there]

[Kane McGoodwin]

He can play, can kick goals, and is quite mobile. He plays a good game and you think he has turned the corner, then he goes quiet again.
Maybe with going to the same team as his brother, it might spur him on.

Sounds like we are waiting to see who we are able to trade in before releasing him to GWS.

 

[Snarls Barkley]

His career has stagnated a bit but I’m not ready to give up on him.

GWS makes a lot of sense as a fit. Had to ask Keeffe to play the forward/ruck role which was never his forte. Maybe if he can string a long number of games together we’ll see Himmelberg make a leap, I’d have him a fair way behind Thilthorpe fighting for the same position.

 

[all seeing eye]

Very much a depth player at GWS, not starting 22 at either club. Probably simliar value to Frampton.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Yeah contracted or uncontracted doesn't really matter for guys like this who clearly have no future at their current club and have limited upside. Future 3rd.

True, but I wonder if we will be keen to hold on to him in case we can’t find more depth from somewhere else, or we get a deal above market price

 

[Colonial]

Keefe is on his way out, tonight has shown we need a replacement for him.
Would like it it be Elliott, think he can do the job until Cads or Leek are ready.

 

[Colonial]

True, but I wonder if we will be keen to hold on to him in case we can’t find more depth from somewhere else, or we get a deal above market price

You havent played him, you arent getting above market price.

 

[Giant Pete]

Same trade value as Frampton was. Future 3rd.

Nah… same trade as Hately.

 

[tiger_tough]

Nah… same trade as Hately.

 

[fuic08]

Nah… same trade as Hately.

Under contract, so ups the value, maybe a pick in the 60s

 

[Jcpdragonx]

has shown glimpses in the past, not the worst get

 

[Giant Pete]

Under contract, so ups the value, maybe a pick in the 60s

We’ll take him for nothing the following year

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Don't think the issue will be agreeing on trade value, moreso whether Crows have a similar trade in.

 

[Eddie Murphy]

Nah… same trade as Hately.

Good luck picking up a contracted player in the pre-season draft

 

[Eddie Murphy]

I can’t see crows letting him go until they bring in backup up ruck depth (without him we’ve only 3 players that can play ruck). Once that’s done though a f3 should get it done.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

You havent played him, you arent getting above market price.

I didn’t say we would, but he’s contracted, we don’t have to release him

 

[Giant Pete]

Good luck picking up a contracted player in the pre-season draft

The following year? We’ll just do what you did with Hately

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

What offer up a pick to GWS in the 30's that Jason McCartney refused to take wanting something better and then got too busy with other deals he had going on so the trade window closed and he then got nought.

We offered overs which they refused to accept... which isn't our problem.

Berg going to GWS imo is contingent on whether Choi is traded to the Crows.

Doubt their will be quibbling over draft picks. Future 3rd should be around the mark.

 

[Eddie Murphy]

The following year? We’ll just do what you did with Hately

We’re not asking an early second for him though. Regardless, if he dishes up a similar season next year you guys will probably then get him as a delisted player.

 

[Giant Pete]

We’re not asking an early second for him though. Regardless, if he dishes up a similar season next year you guys will probably then get him as a delisted player.

I don’t even know if we are into him. All I’m saying is we will come to the table like you did re. Hately.

 

[Cleric]

The following year? We’ll just do what you did with Hately

Dude, if you are that salty about Hatley still, you can pick him up for free as a desisted FA. You can get him back for the same price we paid.

 

[Giant Pete]

Dude, if you are that salty about Hatley still, you can pick him up for free as a desisted FA. You can get him back for the same price we paid.

Lol… it’s not about Hately. It’s about the AFC. All good though. What goes around comes around.

 

[Orange Agent]

What offer up a pick to GWS in the 30's that Jason McCartney refused to take wanting something better and then got too busy with other deals he had going on so the trade window closed and he then got nought.

Its was a pick we wouldnt use.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Its was a pick we wouldnt use.

Yet was an overpayment...

 

[Giant Strides]

We’ll take him for nothing the following year

We're not going to argue over a late pick for EH.

We (almost) never do, we (mostly) just get trades done.

Shiel, Hately & Jezza among the few we took right to the wire.

 

[Orange crush]

We're not going to argue over a late pick for EH.

We (almost) never do, we (mostly) just get trades done.

Shiel, Hately & Jezza among the few we took right to the wire.

Indeed we even gave the tigers a couple of late picks last year as we wouldn’t use them