Constable, Parfitt, Narkle, Cockatoo, Fogarty, Clark, is a good start to a future midfield
Fogarty is useless
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Constable, Parfitt, Narkle, Cockatoo, Fogarty, Clark, is a good start to a future midfield
Are you ok?He’s doing the job that is asked off him
More than what Constable is doing at this stage hence his stint in the VFL
Looking forward to your next inane snarking clueless comment
Just waiting for your next snark attack of Guthrie that’s allAre you ok?
It do. A young strappi mb g ruckman for a 32 year old ex champ. YepHaha
Hahaha you don't really believe that surely.
No he isnt. Real talen6 but young. He'll be very good for usFogarty is useless
No he isnt. Real talen6 but young. He'll be very good for us
It's only his 2nd season and his 2nd season was injured plagued....Can't kick,slow, one paced others on list will overtake him
Who TT or Woods.... thats what I mean ..its not a game of trade/draft on bigfooty or even the nba. The players must agree... and then the clubs have to also agree...it narrows the options of who might be available.North wouldnt trade him full stop...
Can't kick,slow, one paced others on list will overtake him
It's only his 2nd season and his 2nd season was injured plagued....
In a smorgasbord of choice sure ... but doesn't quite work like that. If was to choose id say I would rather TarThomas ..
Who TT or Woods.... thats what I mean ..its not a game of trade/draft on bigfooty or even the nba. The players must agree... and then the clubs have to also agree...it narrows the options of who might be available.
I known there is speculation..but some of that is because he is a Preagent. What would you pay for him ...?
They wont let him go.
Id be keen on wood he'd be a good third tall fwd my issue is he's not proven enough to trade a R1 for and they wont trade him for our R2. Might need to involve a player if there was trade.
Pure I know that.. he is future top 50 player ..he is not going anywhere..
My issue with Wood..he misses too many setshots..
Hes technically a very good kick though so its likely mental which can be fixed.
Btw i wouldnt give a R2 for him if it were last years draft but i think this years is weaker.
Also people keep talking about needing more young mids on our board..GWS will need a ruck with Simpson and probably Mummy going..if they cant get Jacobs or Ryder to leave SA we could do worse than offer them one of our surplus rucks and a decent pick and see if it could move someone like Bonar/Caldwell/XOH. (I was tempted to say in a trade for Patton tbh but he has a lot of injury risk).
Mentioned it earlier, Brent Prismall requested a trade after season 2, and he showed a bit of promise at that age. That was about 11 years ago.I know I know... I honestly just don't want to lose him, as he has huge potential not just as a player but a future captain, and like you said I can't remember the last 20 year old player on our list wanting to leave.
As you said in a previous post, the Junior Abletts, Chapman, Johnson, Scarlett, Enright played many years of 2s before playing 1s.
But I do admit he should be playing AFL but I just hope he can see the light at the end of the tunnel before jumping ship.
Young strapping ruckman...he's 28!!!It do. A young strappi mb g ruckman for a 32 year old ex champ. Yep
as good a tackler as there is and averaged ridiculous numbers in his last year in u/18s. Something like 145 CD points a game. I understand it's easy to turf the kids quickly if they aren't cemented in the team but Fogarty has hardly looked at the midfield yet, his actual preferred position. He might not make it, but he just might too.Can't kick,slow, one paced others on list will overtake him
I call it the Selwood syndromeThese days people expect these kids to be good players from the moment they walk into the club. Nothing wrong spending a couple of years developing in the VFL. In Fogarty's case, injuries have stalled his development.
Small size, slow and can't kick. Won't make itas good a tackler as there is and averaged ridiculous numbers in his last year in u/18s. Something like 145 CD points a game. I understand it's easy to turf the kids quickly if they aren't cemented in the team but Fogarty has hardly looked at the midfield yet, his actual preferred position. He might not make it, but he just might too.
Lol get your hand off itSmall size, slow and can't kick. Won't make it
These days people expect these kids to be good players from the moment they walk into the club. Nothing wrong spending a couple of years developing in the VFL. In Fogarty's case, injuries have stalled his development.
Can't kick,slow, one paced others on list will overtake him
Just isn't working for them. Not sure who I'd want though. They have a fair few star looking inside mids but I would say the ones we want we can't get and the ones we can get we don't want. I wonder if there's any they're actively looking to move on?One would think Melb will be looking to move a player or two ... something is quite off balance about their side ....