Prediction Round 13: Changes Vs Hawthorn + pre-match discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

How do we fit all of Fyfe, Switta, Taberner, Walters, Chapman into a winning side? Obvious potential outs are Hughes, Tucker and Meek.
Yeah Those three are definitely out.

Fyfe <-- Tucker
Tabs <--- Meek
Chappy <--- Hughes

Switta... hmm..ahhh whispers Banfield?
 
Out: Hughes, Banfield, Tucker and Meek.

In: Chapman, Switkowski, Fyfe and Taberner.

FB: Ryan Pearce Walker
HB: Young Cox Chapman
C: Clark Brayshaw Acres
HF: Fred Lobb Switkowski
FF: Schultz Tabs Logue

R: Darcy Brodie Serong

I: Aish Fyfe Mundy Colyer
 
OUT: Tucker, Meek, Hughes, ... ???
IN: Fyfe, Tabs, Switta, Walters, Chapman, Treacy

Catch ya later Tucker, got your 100 games but it's time now. See ya later son!

Was going to do the other outs but it's legit hard to think of any more that should be dropped.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

In: Fyfe, Switta
Out: Hughes, Tucker

Then the rest depends on injury recovery.

Treacy is doing well at Peel but not enough to dislodge someone in the side.
 
Out: Hughes, Banfield, Tucker and Meek.

In: Chapman, Switkowski, Fyfe and Taberner.

FB: Ryan Pearce Walker
HB: Young Cox Chapman
C: Clark Brayshaw Acres
HF: Fred Lobb Switkowski
FF: Schultz Tabs Logue

R: Darcy Brodie Serong

I: Aish Fyfe Mundy Colyer


You seriously think Banfield will get dropped?
 
I would honestly still drop Banfield for Switta/Walters as like for like, if I was selecting a team I thought would be best chance to win.

While acknowledging that was Banner’s best ever game and he won’t be dropped.
Hard to say when he was our most productive forward. But I like him as sub.
 
I would honestly still drop Banfield for Switta/Walters as like for like, if I was selecting a team I thought would be best chance to win.

While acknowledging that was Banner’s best ever game and he won’t be dropped.
Yeah I would as well, but we all know he's not gonna get dropped for kicking 4 goals.
 
Tucker is only one who can get dropped based on performance.

Hughes and Meek might get dropped based on last ones in, first ones out.

We should hold fire on selections as every week we’ve had put we weren’t expecting.
 
Don’t think Chapman will be ready nor do I think we should risk him. I’d let Hughes have another game and make the switch after the bye.

Walters may be better off having another week. We’ll bring him back in eventually but as an older player maybe his injury will be better off for the extra week’s rest.

Taberner for Meek is obvious.

Tucker out for anyone is obvious. That Fyfe guy might offer more.

It was a dumb act by Switta and he may need to wait a bit to get into the side. Obvious choice for medical sub if he stays out.
 
We need to win a game in the rain just for a psychological boost if it comes up in finals.

Good chance next week before the bye leave it all out there and knock it out the way.

Yeah, it’d be a good bogey off our back for the year. Beat Geelong in Geelong, the two top sides, our bogey team in Carlton. Just need to win in the wet.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top