Only Taranto would I trade a Future 1st for, and all our other picks too lol - one of my favourite players and an absolute gun.
To your other point, anyone rational - even the Tigers - knew that trading with us for a Future 1st was never going to net a Top 10 pick, given the talent we brought in and how close we were last year. Different for Collingwood though, as they barely scraped into finals, had a miracle win over WC, and then traded away Treloar, Stephenson and Phillips - whilst still somehow expecting to make finals after they got completely destroyed by us.
There's a reason they're begging for Wells and we're not begging for Ned Guy, haha
Id say if we project P15 plus then Hopper for our R1 is probably reasonable. Coming into his prime and has still 100 plus games to come but the codicil is who we can pick for zero as a FA and how the draft looks..