who are you thinking?
Cox and grundy both looked sore last game, could be carrying something
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
who are you thinking?
I’d argue having one less tall cost us against west coast.Does this mean change our attack style that has worked for 1 and a half seasons and almost delivered a premiership?
Cox and grundy both looked sore last game, could be carrying something
Reids retirement can't come soon enough. At least clubs like Hawthorn have the balls to drop cooked players while the Pies are still a boys club.
Club can't see it, but he is a handicap to the forward line
I’d be surprised if his mobility is anything special compared to small to mid forwards.I think the big confusion for most on here is they don’t realise Mihocek is no more a key forward than De Goey is.
His key strengths are mobility, ground balls and ground coverage
Reid is a good inclusion against the Dogs whose tall defenders are weak
Reid’s been decent himself but our forwardline seems to function a lot less effectively with him there than say a Cox. This week with three talls (if we go in as named) will be interesting but I think we’ll find we lose the ability to lock the ball in our forward line (worsened by losing Stephenson already) will be a huge threat to our chances, particularly as the Bulldogs have a decent enough midfield that has already shown it’s capable of getting on top of our mids even with Grundy rucking.Reid isn’t cooked if you have watched him this year without your blinkers.
Reid’s been decent himself but our forwardline seems to function a lot less effectively with him there than say a Cox. This week with three talls (if we go in as named) will be interesting but I think we’ll find we lose the ability to lock the ball in our forward line (worsened by losing Stephenson already) will be a huge threat to our chances, particularly as the Bulldogs have a decent enough midfield that has already shown it’s capable of getting on top of our mids even with Grundy rucking.
Yeah I agree, on Reid’s form in isolation that he’s been stiff. How he gels with the team and our structure is my huge question mark. I’m worried about another Fremantle scenario.Reid deserves another shot (Daicos is also stiff) but I think Libbas absence offsets Stepho’s.......looking forward to this game.
You're joking right.Daicos will leave the club at the end of the season.
Bucks clearly hates Greeks.
Very strange post. Not sure if Sirius.Reids retirement can't come soon enough. At least clubs like Hawthorn have the balls to drop cooked players while the Pies are still a boys club.
Club can't see it, but he is a handicap to the forward line
Cox sore? Interesting.Cox and grundy both looked sore last game, could be carrying something
Very strange post. Not sure if Sirius.
Boys club?
You really think people are selected because they’re all friends?
Doesn’t really explain how come Reid has been dropped various times in the past few seasons.
He’s coming closer to the end that’s for sure.Perhaps not boys club. That's off the mark. Thanks for pulling me up on that.
Playing Reid is like playing Cloke in his last few seasons. They're cooked players and better to look at future players like Daicos for Stevo imo.
Watching Reid reminds me of a geriatric tube man from a used car lot.
Except if we look slow and fail miserably, I'll be here saying I told you soWell, there goes that theory ;-)
If anyone has been watching the VFL then Reid is a no brainer, Daicos and Crocker have not been up to scratch, good selection IMO
If anyone has been watching the VFL then Reid is a no brainer, Daicos and Crocker have not been up to scratch, good selection IMO
Been a long time since last game. Good for recovery.Cox and grundy both looked sore last game, could be carrying something
Does this mean change our attack style that has worked for 1 and a half seasons and almost delivered a premiership?
Stick to the Sam Murray threadFoxFooty at the half time discussion stated that the final Collingwood team was in and its Reid in for Stephenson.
3 forward 50 talls?
If I were a betting man I’d be shifting my money to the Dogs.
Stupid selection for a team that lacks speed and has lost a speedster.